Modem vs router Spectrum comparison

In terms of home internet setup, Spectrum, like many other internet service providers (ISP), offers several options: modems, routers, and modem router combos. With so many options, choosing the ideal setup for your needs can be confusing. In addition, most people often mix up modems with routers and use these two terms interchangeably without realizing that they are two distinctive devices with very different jobs: a modem lets you connect one device directly to the internet, while a router links to the modem to get the signal and enables multiple devices to access the internet.

This distinction plays a crucial role in optimizing your home internet performance. So, to help you determine whether you need a modem, a router, or both for the best internet experience with Spectrum, our research team and I, as a Cybernews expert, have joined forces to investigate online reviews, user feedback, and the information provided by Spectrum. Here is everything you need to know.

What is a Spectrum modem?

A Spectrum modem is a device that connects your home to the ISP. Think of it like a two-way bridge between your home and Spectrum’s network. The modem is connected to Spectrum's internet through a coaxial cable to your home wall outlet.

Here is how it works: when powered up, it translates the digital data traveling from your device (e.g., computer) to the ISP into an analog format that the internet can understand and vice-versa.

As a cybersecurity expert, I particularly appreciate that Spectrum gives its customers enough choices without compromising speed, compatibility, and security. For instance, you can get a Spectrum-compliant modem tested and certified for performance and compatibility for free.

Alternatively, you have the option to purchase a Spectrum-approved model manufactured by some of the best brands on the market, such as the Motorola MB8600, the ARRIS (SB8200) cable modem, and the NETGEAR Nighthawk CM1200, or use your own hardware.

No matter which one you pick, ensure the device is listed among those authorized to work on the Spectrum network and that it is data over cable service interface specifications (DOCSIS) 3.0 or 3.1 compliant.

DOCSIS 3.0 modems offer a maximum download speed of 1Gbps. On top of it, they use the WPA2 protocol to protect the information transmitted from prying eyes through data encryption and authentication. On the other hand, DOCSIS 3.1 models support up to 10Gbps download speeds. That is ten times faster. Additionally, DOCSIS 3.1 modems include WPA3, a more advanced and robust security protocol.

What is a Spectrum router?

A router depends on the modem. Without it, it doesn’t work. Once the router is connected to it, it creates a local area network (LAN) where devices (e.g., smartphones, laptops, and television) can communicate and connect to the internet simultaneously.

When the router receives the converted internet signal from the modem, it distributes it to the connected devices via Wi-Fi or Ethernet cable. The router manages the incoming and outgoing internet traffic within the LAN. It keeps your connections secure by hiding your devices’ IP addresses and acts as a bouncer determining who can or cannot access your network.

Spectrum-compatible routers include dual-band connectivity (2.4 and 5GHz bands). They allow you to select the strongest available network and advanced security options. The WPA2 security protocol protects your network access with password and encryption.

As a Spectrum customer, you have several choices in terms of hardware and features. Based on the reviews I have analyzed, the Netgear WNDR3800 N600 Premium Edition Dual Band Gigabit Wireless Router, the ASUS RT-AX3000 Ultra-Fast Dual Band Gigabit Wireless Router, and the TP-Link AX1800 Wi-Fi 6 Router V4 (Archer AX21) are the three best spectrum-compatible modems on the market.

In addition, if you live in a large house or enjoy surfing the net from your home deck, you will love to know that Spectrum-compatible routers support mesh networks. A mesh is a combination of satellite signal extenders (e.g., Spectrum Pods) that expands your Wi-Fi coverage and guarantees a seamless connectivity experience.

What is a router-modem combo?

With the increased popularity of home smart devices (e.g., fridges, security cameras, and televisions), router-modem combos (i.e., gateways) have become increasingly common. This is understandable because they are convenient and easy to set up.

A router-modem combo integrates both the modem and router functionalities in just one box, helping you to save space and reduce the number of cables around the home. So, if you can have just one device that includes the features of a modem and a router, you may wonder why separate routers and modems are still around. Let’s find it out.

While a router-modem combo can save you space, it also has limited customization and upgrade flexibility. For instance, if you have a router-modem combo and want a more powerful or next-generation router, you will have to replace the whole box, even if your modem works fine.

Moreover, Spectrum-compatible router-modem combos are affected by the same restrictions applied to single modems and routers. As a result, you get no Spectrum technical support, no phone service, and a limited choice of speed-tier types that may not match the level of performance you are aiming for.

If despite these limitations you are still interested in this solution, here I have listed what real users consider the three best compatible Spectrum-authorized router-modem combo on the market:

• NETGEAR Nighthawk Modem Router Combo (CAX30)
• ARRIS (G34) Cable Modem Router Combo - Fast DOCSIS 3.1 Gigabit Wi-Fi 6 (AX3000)
• Motorola MG7700 Modem Wi-Fi Router Combo with Power Boost

Do I need both a modem and a router?

It depends on your needs and priorities. Let's say you want to access the internet with your computer. A modem is enough to do the job, as it connects you directly to the Spectrum network. Then your wife comes home. She also wants to use her laptop to check her emails while your son wants to watch his favorite series on the television.

Yet a modem allows you to connect only one device at a time. So, if you have a family or must connect two or more devices simultaneously to the internet, you need both a modem and a router. If you or anyone in your family works from home, you will also need both devices.

A router comprises extra security features to help you keep your organization's sensitive data secure. It also offers increased performance when attending video calls, accessing heavy web applications, or downloading large files. The same goes for gaming and streaming your favorite movies. You cannot do that only with a modem.

Spectrum’s wide range of equipment can cover all these needs. Yet, some Spectrum’s hardware may lack advanced features for tech-savvy users, such as enhanced security options (e.g., WPA3), increased Wi-Fi coverage, or other state-of-the-art settings.

Key differences and similarities between modem and router

Internet connectivity

Modems enable you to connect one device directly to Spectrum's network. A router connects to the modem. It distributes and manages all the incoming and outgoing traffic across all devices within the LAN network via Wi-Fi or Ethernet cables.

Network coverage

A Wi-Fi router works like a radio. It broadcasts electromagnetic waves to multiple devices. Thus, having good coverage can be challenging as the signal’s strength and stability depends on various factors. A modem does not have this problem as it connects a single device directly to Spectrum.

Working principle

Modems decode signals exchanged between a device and Spectrum. Routers create a LAN network and connect multiple devices to the internet through a modem. Without a router, each device would need its dedicated modem.

IP address

When you use a modem, your device is assigned a Spectrum’s public IP address. With a router, your device’s IP address remains private. The modem assigns Spectrum's public IP address to the router, which, in turn, distributes a private IP address to every device on the network.

Wired vs wireless connections

A modem is a no-frills solution that offers a wired connection to a single device. A router takes your internet experience to another level. It enables you to use wired and wireless networking and connect all the devices you want.

Security

Routers include a built-in firewall filtering incoming traffic and protecting your network from snooping and Malware. Most routers offer strong WPA3 authentication, encryption, and parental controls. Modems don’t offer these additional layers of security as they focus more on connectivity.

Ports

A modem has two ports. One connects the modem to Spectrum, the other to your computer or router. Routers have multiple ports: A WAN port for connecting the box to the modem and other Ethernet ports that can be utilized to distribute internet access to connected devices.

Spectrum modem vs router: pricing

One of the things I like about Spectrum is that all its voice and internet plans include a free-of-charge Spectrum-compliant modem that has passed certification testing for optimal performance. And if Spectrum decides to increase the network speed and your modem is not powerful enough, you are entitled to a free hardware replacement.

If you also want a router, you can rent it for as low as $10 per month or purchase a third-party Spectrum-approved top-of-the-line device. Some selected plans even include a pre-configured complimentary Wi-Fi router.

While a Spectrum compatible modem-router combo is, on average, between $100 and $200 cheaper, opting for a separate modem and router will save you some money in the long run - and here is why. Routers are usually replaced every three to four years. Modems last for ages. So, if you purchase two independent boxes, when the time comes, you will only have to substitute – and pay – for one.

The same goes when you decide to upgrade your actual Spectrum plan. The modem will probably work, but you may need to swap your actual router for one that supports faster speed. If one device is damaged, you will not need to replace both. But, if your router does not work, the modem will still give you access to the internet.

What to look for in Spectrum modems and routers

• Compatibility. Ensure the device is Spectrum-approved. You can have the best router and modem on the market, including all the whistles and bells. Nevertheless, if they are incompatible with Spectrum, they will be worth nothing.
• Internet speed support: Match the device with your Spectrum plan’s speed requirements. Purchasing a high-performance router when you have a Spectrum plan that guarantees only 100Mbps download will not make your internet faster. It will only cost you more money.
• DOCSIS standard. Look for DOCSIS 3.1 for faster speeds and better efficiency. DOCSIS 3.1 advanced technology ensures a more stable and reliable connection that is ideal for online gaming, HD streaming, video conferencing, and more.
• Security features. Check for WPA3, VPN support, and built-in firewalls. They will help you protect your sensitive data (e.g., credit card numbers and passwords) from snooping and Malware.
• Coverage area. Ensure the router can cover your whole home adequately. If it does not, verify that it supports network mesh.
• Number of ports. Consider how many wired connections you’ll need. Wi-Fi signals can be much less stable than Ethernet as they may be subjected to interference. So, if you have a lot of devices that require a powerful, stable connection, make sure you choose a router with enough Ethernet ports.
• Firmware updates. Ensure regular updates for security and performance enhancements. Failing to do so will leave your devices at risk of attacks and impact their performance.

Final word on modem vs router Spectrum

The latest advancements in technology have made connecting to the internet easier than ever. However, before you set up your home network with a Spectrum modem, router, or a router-modem combo or even upgrading to a mesh network, there are a few key things you need to know.

For instance, it is essential to understand the difference between a modem and a router. The modem connects your home to the ISP, while the router distributes the internet signals to connected devices.

Furthermore, with so many possible combinations and features, choosing the right setup for your individual needs is critical for a smooth, secure, reliable, and powerful internet experience.

This Cybernews research team’s analysis provided you with the best advice and all the knowledge you need to make an informed decision and optimize your Spectrum home connection. Put into practice what you have just learned. Start building your very own personalized Spectrum home network.

FAQ