HostGator vs InMotion Hosting: are they equally good?
In this HostGator vs InMotion comparison, I’ll go through the differences between the 2 providers. I’ll focus on pricing, ease of use, performance, security, and customer support.
Bold claims, decades of experience, and long lists of hosting solutions – those are just some of the things that HostGator and InMotion Hosting have in common.
But, in trying to decide between HostGator vs InMotion, it’s better to zero in on the differences. They’ll be far more telling on which is the better provider for you.
That’s why you’ll find all that and more in this HostGator vs InMotion Hosting review. Let’s get cracking.
HostGator vs InMotion Hosting: general info
Both HostGator and InMotion Hosting are very well-known providers in the hosting market. And for a good reason. Both providers are mostly known due to their beginner-friendly management approach, affordable prices, and good performance.
Here’s a quick overview of both providers’ main hosting features. If you’re also curious to know the final verdict, feel free to skip to the conclusion.
|Price from||From $2.29/mo||From $2.75/mo|
|Payment types||Credit card, PayPal, check, money order||Credit/Debit card, PayPal, check, money orders, bank wires|
|Hosting types||Shared, Managed WordPress, VPS, Reseller, and Dedicated hosting plans||Shared, WordPress, VPS, Cloud, Reseller, and Dedicated hosting plans|
|Control panel||Account management panel +cPanel||Native user interface +cPanel|
|Server locations||The US||The US|
|Security||SSLs, malware and DDoS protection, web application firewall||SSL, server-level firewall|
|Support||24/7 live chat, tickets, phone, and Skype||24/7 live chat, 24/7 phone, and email support|
|Website migration||Free automated WordPress website transfers||One free WordPress/cPanel migration and inter-server migration|
|Extras||Email accounts||Email accounts|
|Money-back guarantee||90 days||45 days|
HostGator vs InMotion Hosting: pricing comparison
Between the two, InMotion Hosting offers cheaper options. While HostGator’s cheapest shared hosting plan costs $2.75/mo, InMotion prices for shared hosting start from just $2.29/mo.
Here’s what both providers have to offer in terms of different types of hosting services:
|Hosting type||HostGator||InMotion Hosting|
|Shared||Yes, starts at $2.75/mo||Yes, starts at $2.29/m|
|WordPress||Yes, starts at $5.95/mo||Yes, starts at $4.99/mo|
|Cloud||Yes, starts at $4.95/mo||No|
|VPS||Yes, starts at $19.95/mo||Yes, starts at $17.99/mo|
|WooCommerce||No||Yes, starts at $4.99/mo|
|Reseller||Yes, starts at $19.95/mo||Yes, starts at $15.39/mo|
|Dedicated||Yes, starts at $89.98/mo||Yes, starts at $99.99/mo|
While both providers come with a very wide range of hosting options, the most popular one still remains shared hosting. And that’s exactly what I’ll be focusing on in this comparison.
Before we get to the nitty-gritty, note that all HostGator shared hosting plans get a free domain for a year. Whereas, InMotion Hosting provides the same deal for all plans apart from Core. If you’re on Core, InMotion Hosting offers a domain from $17.99/mo.
Now, let’s talk about each provider’s cheapest shared hosting packages. To begin with, there are a few similarities – both providers include a free SSL and unlimited bandwidth in their entry plans.
Now here’s how they differ:
- HostGator’s Hatchling ($2.75/mo) – allows hosting 1 site and includes unlimited disk space, unlimited email accounts, a free custom domain, Gators website builder, and server-level firewall.
- InMotion Hosting’s Core ($2.29/mo) – allows hosting 2 sites and includes 100GB storage, 10 email addresses, and a free website builder, as well as hack & malware protection, spam experts, and daily backups.
This is a tough InMotion vs HostGator battle but I’d give the win to InMotion Hosting. Not only is it slightly cheaper, but it also allows hosting 2 websites. Plus, its extensive package of security features pretty much seals the deal.
But, those are just the cheapest plans and both hosts have many more options. So, let’s find out which plans offer the best value for money.
When it comes to shared hosting, HostGator offers 3 affordable plans ranging from $2.75/mo up to $5.25/mo.
When talking about the best plan, HostGator recommends the Baby one, and I must agree. For less than a dollar extra a month, you’re free from the one-website limit. Meanwhile, the Business plan is slightly expensive for the additions it offers.
To secure the lowest price, go for the Baby plan, with a 36-month subscription. This is over 60% cheaper than the monthly subscription. The first upfront payment is $126, and the renewal price will come up to $358.20.
InMotion Hosting, meanwhile, has 4 plans priced between $2.29/mo and $12.99/mo.
To get the best value for money, your best bet is Launch. The plan comes with unlimited websites, storage, and email accounts. More so, although Power is priced the same, its renewal rate is much higher, and it doesn’t offer any significant advantage over Launch. Meanwhile, Pro’s price is overall too steep for what it offers.
To cut the best deal, opt for Launch with a 36-month subscription. This works out to $179.64 in total and will renew at $431.64 for the next 3 years.
Now one more thing to note, both hosts are quite different in terms of money-back policies. While InMotion Hosting offers a 90-day money-back guarantee, HostGator gives only half of that – a 45-day money-back guarantee.
Ultimately, InMotion Hosting is the winner in this InMotion Hosting vs HostGator battle for pricing. Its starting price is lower, while all plans include a much more comprehensive security suite and marketing tools.
Hosting management: ease of use
When it comes to ease of use, both HostGator and InMotion Hosting put simplicity first. HostGator uses a native user interface, while InMotion Hosting utilizes an Account Management Panel (AMP). Regardless, both hosts also offer a standard cPanel for all website management-related tasks.
Both providers’ native dashboards are quite similar in terms of functionality. While design-wise the two are seemingly very different, they both offer the same features – billing management, cPanel shortcuts, and access to the cPanel.
Now talking about cPanel, the similarities continue.
HostGator offers a basic cPanel with a custom skin, to match the overall provider’s design. The panel itself is very much standard, with a simplistic layout that won’t cause any problems to a beginner or an advanced user.
Here, you'll find the main features like 1-click app installer, domain, email, and SSL management, as well as file, database, manual backup management, and more.
Now talking about InMotion’s cPanel, it’s just as functional and well structured, with all the main features that are needed to run a site smoothly.
From the cPanel dashboard, you can easily manage domains, emails, databases, files, and more. Additionally, this is also where you can install a content management system (CMS) with the help of the Softaculous one-click installer.
However, one significant difference between HostGator and InMotion Hosting lies with the SSL activation. While both providers offer automatic SSL activation, sometimes it has to be activated manually. It’s common practice to do so in the cPanel, yet InMotion has placed its SSL activation/management functionality in its native user interface exclusively. So do not be surprised when you can’t find it in cPanel, it’s in the AMP.
All in all, both hosts are just as simplistic and well-structured in terms of simplicity. With an easy-to-navigate native panel plus, user beloved cPanel both HostGator and InMotion Hosting will be easy enough for beginners and advanced users alike. At the same time, a slightly more modern HostGator's native user interface is easier to navigate.
HostGator vs InMotion Hosting performance
When it comes to performance, HostGator was a slightly more reliable provider, with almost-perfect >99.99% uptime and better server response time. Meanwhile, InMotion Hosting was blazing fast in terms of the site’s loading speed.
Uptime and response time
To see how reliable each provider is, both HostGator and InMotion Hosting were monitored for over 2 months.
In this time, HostGator had only 3 outages that resulted in 5 minutes of downtime. This has ultimately led to an outstanding >99.99% uptime, which is a significantly better result than the official 99/9% uptime guarantee promises.
In contrast, its average response time rounded up to 525ms – a little less impressive, yet still better than the industry average of 600ms.
Now talking about InMotion Hosting, in 2 months, the provider experienced 3 outages or 16 minutes of downtime. This has led to a similarly reliable uptime of 99.98%, which is very much in line with the official 99.9% uptime guarantee.
As for response time, InMotion Hosting averaged at 759ms, which is slightly above the market average of 600ms. While it could definitely use a boost to speed things up, I don’t see any major issues to be worried about. Plus, there was also a drop in response times towards the end of the monitoring period, so there’s a reason to be hopeful.
For this HostGator vs InMotion Hosting face-off, HostGator has the lead with near-perfect uptime and slightly better average response time.
Next up is a speed test to determine which provider is faster in terms of the website’s load time.
Before we go on to analyze the results, there are 2 main measures I’ll be evaluating:
- Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) – this shows the time in which the largest file on the site (image, video, font, etc.) is loaded. As this is one of the measures Google takes into account when ranking its search result page, keep it under 2.5s for best results.
- Fully Loaded Time – this is the time in which all the files on your site get fully loaded. For the best user experience and reasonably low bounce-off rates, keep it under 3s.
And, to keep things fair, both providers are hosted in and tested from the US. Speaking of, both hosts only have data centers in the US. Hence, note that you’ll see the best speed results if your website targets visitors from North America.
Back to the test, HostGator was very speedy with an LCP of just 1.1s. That’s far faster than the 2.5s cut-off that Google considers to be good.
Meanwhile, its fully loaded time was just 1.2s.
At the same time, the provider’s Fully Loaded Time was just as speedy – just 1.2 seconds. Not even a half of recommended maximum of 3 seconds.
Now, although HostGator was very fast, InMotion Hosting blew it out of the water with even better results. InMotion Hosting’s LCP was at a remarkably speedy 663ms. This leaves a lot of room until you hit the undesirable 2.5s.
Additionally, LCP was not the only impressive measure; the host's Fully Loaded Time took less than a second – just 825ms. That makes InMotion Hosting one of the fastest hosting providers in the market.
Both HostGator and InMotion Hosting proved to be very fast. But, as they said, numbers don’t lie, and the numbers showed that InMotion Hosting is a noticeably faster provider.
As a whole, both providers did well performance-wise. HostGator was a slightly more reliable hosting solution, but InMotion Hosting was notably faster with peak load time and fairly similar uptime.
When it comes to security, InMotion Hosting is a clear winner. HostGator offers the bare minimums for free and everything else comes at an extra cost as add-on security features. InMotion Hosting, contrastingly, provides more security measures for free even for its entry plan.
Both HostGator and InMotion Hosting come with an SSL certificate. But, that’s the end of the road for their similarities security-wise.
Instead, HostGator’s security features include:
- Free server-level firewall to filter out malicious traffic and protect against vulnerabilities.
- Positive SSL upgrade included only in the Business plan. But can be purchased for $39.99/year.
- SiteLock Essentials available for $23.88/year. This provides things like daily malware scans, basic CDN, and Google Blacklist monitoring.
- Daily automated website backup and 1-click restore for $23.95/year.
Meanwhile, InMotion Hosting is more generous with its free security measures:
- Hack and malware protection scans and patches for website files.
- DDoS protection by Corero is automatically activated to detect and prevent your server from being flooded by malicious requests.
- Web Application Firewall (WAF) to protect your website from malicious attacks.
- Automatic daily backups and 1-click restore for $24.00/yr.
All in all, HostGator only has the basics, while InMotion Hosting offers a more comprehensive security suite for free. However, it’s a shame that both providers have skipped free automatic backups.
Both HostGator and InMotion Hosting offer quite a number of customer support channels to choose from. The 2 offer 24/7 help via live chat, phone, and email. Additionally, InMotion Hosting also has a ticketing system for assistance. Plus, the duo has extensive knowledge bases, too.
My experience with HostGator’s customer support varies wildly. But more often than not, the wait time on its live chat is short, and the agents are willing and helpful. However, it’s not uncommon for miscommunication or language barriers to get in the way as the provider’s support team is outsourced.
If you prefer to find the information yourself, HostGator has a wide-ranging knowledge base chock-full of articles, guides, and video tutorials. The articles themselves are pretty detailed and very well well-organized for better accessibility.
As for InMotion Hosting, I’ve also contacted its live chat multiple times. Each time, there was virtually no wait time before connecting and the agents were helpful and efficient too. Even better, they don’t just direct you to a knowledge base article to figure things out on your own. That’s always a plus.
Speaking of knowledge base, InMotion Hosting has a huge one filled with detailed articles and step-by-step tutorials. For instance, if you want to decide between InMotion Hosting vs HostGator reseller plans, you’ll find pages and pages of articles to help with your decision.
Overall, both hosts offer high quality and near excellent customer support. Yet, InMotion Hosting has a slight edge as it has more support options and better-trained agents.
HostGator vs InMotion Hosting: final recommendations
All in all, both providers did very well in this HostGator vs InMotion Hosting comparison. HostGator offers affordable hosting plans that are easy to use and reliable. Whereas, InMotion Hosting has even cheaper plans, great speed, and robust security.
|Price||HostGator is affordable with plans starting from $2.75/mo. Yet, InMotion is even cheaper, with prices starting from just $2.29/mo.|
|Ease of use||The hosts are very easy to use and designed with beginners in mind. Both pair their straightforward native interface with cPanel for advanced functionality.|
|Performance||The pair deliver incredible performances. HostGator has marginally better uptime and average response time while InMotion excelled speed-wise with remarkable loading time.|
|Security||InMotion has a more comprehensive security suite, while HostGator only offers the bare minimum. At the same time, both providers do not offer automatic backup.|
|Customer support||The duo have multiple 24/7 support options and huge knowledge bases. But, InMotion has more support channels and more efficient agents, compared to HostGator.|
All things considered, this is no easy battle, as both providers shined in different ways. But, ultimately, InMotion Hosting comes out on top thanks to its cheap pricing, fantastic speed, generous security features, and helpful support.
At the same time, HostGator is just as good of a choice for those looking for a cheap hosting solution for a personal project.
Alternatives to HostGator and InMotion Hosting
HostGator and InMotion Hosting have proved to be excellent service providers. However, they might not suit anyone and any project. If neither of the options was attractive, there are numerous good hosting solutions to choose from. Here are 2 of them to consider.
Hostinger is an extremely popular provider that offers uber-cheap plans, with its shared hosting prices starting as low as $2.59/mo. Despite its affordable pricing, Hostinger delivers top-notch features, performance, and ease of use.
The sister company of HostGator, Bluehost is a massive name in the industry with prices starting at $2.95/mo. As it caters to first-timers a lot, the provider has simplified the setup and site management by automating many of its processes and providing many useful additional tools.
Other HostGator comparisons you might like to check out
- Bluehost vs HostGator
- HostGator vs GoDaddy
- SiteGround vs HostGator
- Namecheap vs HostGator
- Hostinger vs HostGator
- DreamHost vs HostGator
- Wix vs HostGator
Other InMotion Hosting comparisons you’d like to read
HostGator vs InMotion Hosting FAQs
Is HostGator better than InMotion?
No, HostGator isn’t better than InMotion. Generally, InMotion Hosting is cheaper, faster, more secure, and has a better support team.
Which one is cheaper: HostGator or InMotion?
InMotion Hosting is cheaper than HostGator, with prices starting at $2.29/mo, while a HostGator costs $2.75/mo and up.
HostGator vs InMotion for WordPress hosting – which is better?
There’s no clear answer as to which provider is better when it comes to InMotion vs HostGator for WordPress. Both are great for the CMS and have 1-click installers to simplify the setup process.
Do HostGator and InMotion offer money-back guarantees?
Yes, HostGator and InMotion Hosting offer money-back guarantees. HostGator has a 45-day money-back guarantee, while InMotion has a relatively long 90-day money-back guarantee.
Is HostGator faster than InMotion?
No, HostGator isn’t faster than InMotion. InMotion Hosting has better LCP and fully loaded time.
Do I get a free domain with both HostGator and InMotion?
Yes, you get a free domain with both HostGator and InMotion Hosting. The only exception to this is if you’re on InMotion’s Core plan.