Incogni vs Cloaked: which privacy and data removal service should you choose in 2026?

Over the past decade, the internet has become deeply woven into everyday life. UN data shows that around 40% of the global population was online in 2014. By 2025, that figure has climbed to roughly two-thirds of the world. With so many people connected, an enormous amount of personal data is constantly being collected, shared, and stored online. As a result, your information may already be circulating among data brokers, people-search websites, advertisers, and even cybercriminals.

This growing exposure makes data privacy tools more important than ever. Whether you want to limit spam, reduce the risk of identity theft, or simply regain control over your digital footprint, services designed to remove and protect your personal data can help. In this Cloaked vs Incogni comparison, we take a closer look at two well-known privacy tools that aim to safeguard your data – each with a different approach.

Working alongside the Cybernews research team, I evaluated both services using official documentation, product specifications, and real user feedback. In this article, we’ll break down their key features, pricing, strengths, and limitations to help you decide which option best fits your privacy needs.

Incogni vs Cloaked overview

Below is a quick overview of both services. The table highlights their most important features, as well as data broker coverage, pricing and customer support options.

	Incogni	Cloaked
Data brokers covered	Over 420+ (2420+ with custom removals)	Over 140 data brokers, plus other sites
Frequency of records monitoring	Regular re-scans, plus year-round monitoring, monthly progress reports	24/7 identity, SSN, and dark web monitoring, real time alerts, continuous broker scans and removals
International coverage	Data brokers in the US, Canada, EU, UK, CH, NO, IS, LI, Isle of Man	Data brokers in the US and Canada
Starting cost per month	$7.19/month (with a code CYBERNEWS55)	$9.99/month
Money-back guarantee	30-day money-back guarantee on subscriptions	No money-back guarantee stated (unless Cloaked decides otherwise)
Customer service	24/7 support with live chat, phone support (Unlimited)	USA-based support, help center, unlimited chat and email support, live consultations with experts, 24/7 live support for identity-theft resolution

About Incogni

Incogni specializes in automatically removing personal data from data brokers and people-search sites – without bundling other privacy or cybersecurity features like some rivals. It’s a pure data removal tool that handles opt-out requests for you. Incogni also leverages strict privacy laws like GDPR (EU) and CCPA (US) to push removals.

The process is simple: after signing up and giving the platform the information it needs, Incogni scans its large database of over 420+ (2420+ with custom removals) data broker sites to locate information about you. Once the information is located, Incogni sends data removal requests to these data brokers and sites, and then repeats this process periodically (60-90 day intervals).

Incogni is perfect if you’ve had enough of spam calls and marketing, or simply want to reduce how much your name, address, phone, or email address appears on the internet. It’s a straightforward service with a clear promise it delivers on.

About Cloaked

Cloaked is a broad privacy and identity-protection suite. It does offer data broker removal from over 140 data brokers, but unlike Incogni, it includes identity and dark web monitoring, identity masking features, security tools like a password manager, and a spam/scam call blocker – to mention a few. Also unlike Incogni, Cloaked adds $1 million in identity theft insurance, and 24/7 identity theft resolution help.

To begin, start with a free security scan to see if your phone number or personal data is already compromised. After verifying the number, Cloaked shows you the risks, and you can get a personalized risk report. You can then download Cloaked’s browser extension or mobile app and subscribe to unlock the full suite. Once subscribed, you can create “Cloaked Identities” – or aliases – to mask your real info online, while Cloaked handles data removals for you.

Cloaked is for you if you want to mask, monitor, and manage your online identity and data trail. It’s perfect for privacy-conscious people, as well as those who don’t want to give out their real contact information.

Incogni vs Cloaked: feature comparison

Both of these services protect your online identity, but they’re different – Incogni is a pure removal tool, while Cloaked bundles security features and identity theft insurance along with their data removal program. Here’s a features comparison table, plus which service I think wins in the features department.

	Incogni	Cloaked
Data broker removal	Yes, over 420+ (2420+ with custom removals)	Over 140 brokers
Alias tools (email, phone)	No	Yes – generate email, phone, credit card aliases
Dark web monitoring	No	Yes – monitors for exposed emails, SSN, passwords, personal data
Real-time alerts	No – periodic progress reports instead	Yes – alerts for identity exposure, spam, and suspicious activity
Identity theft insurance	No	Yes – up to $1M coverage included on all paid plans
Password manager	No	Yes
Mobile app + autofill	Yes – web-first platform with basic Android app, no autofill	iOS/Android apps, plus browser extension autofill
Custom removal requests	Yes – users can submit URLs outside the broker list	Not supported
Family plan availability	Yes	Yes
VPN access	No – (not native to Incogni, but possible with Surfshark One+ bundle)	No VPN currently, but in development
2FA and biometric login	Yes – 2FA enabled	Yes – Face ID, Touch ID, biometric access

Cloaked is the clear winner in features because of the sheer breadth of privacy tools it provides. Though its data removal is not nearly as specialized or geographically wide as Incogni’s, it provides features Incogni doesn’t – alias generation, app integration, insurance up to $1 million, and identity theft monitoring. Also, features like a VPN and “AI Defense” threat detection are upcoming. While Incogni’s data removal coverage is far more comprehensive, that also doesn’t necessarily equal better protection – it all depends how it’s handled by the company.

Incogni is the clear winner for doing one job right: removing your data from brokers and external sites – including sending ongoing opt-outs and even accepting custom URL submissions. It’s a no-nonsense solution for that, and it doesn’t attempt to cram in a bunch of other features. One other plus is that it leverages established privacy laws to support data removal.

Ultimately, the choice depends on what you need: a serious data removal tool or a broad identity protection suite. Neither of these services excels in both categories. However, features-wise, I pick Cloaked as the winner – especially given that several useful features are in development.

Incogni vs Cloaked: pricing and value

The pricing models for the two services are quite different – Incogni unlocks features and user slots as you go up the tiers, while Cloaked doesn’t paywall features – limiting just the user slots. For example, Incogni starts at $15.98/month (Standard plan, data removals, no custom data removal, one user), while Cloaked starts at $12.49/month (Individual plan, all features, one user). When billed annually, Cloaked’s entry-level plan drops to $9.99/month, while Incogni’s becomes cheaper than Cloaked – at $7.99/month.

Incogni’s highest tier – Family Unlimited ($45.98/month) – unlocks support for up to five users and unlimited custom removals – crucial if you want to process removal requests for sites not included in the default broker list. You also get family account management, plus live phone support.

In comparison, Cloaked’s higher tier plan – Family ($29.99/month) – covers you and three other members. Other than the price and user slots, it’s identical to the entry-level plan – with data removal, call protection, real-time exposure alerts, unlimited aliases, identity theft insurance, security tools, and USA-based support.

Though Incogni’s pricing page is easier to understand than Cloaked’s, Cloaked ultimately has more “bang for your buck” because of the added value – the features and insurance. However, Cloaked is the more expensive service overall. In Cloaked’s case, for one user, I recommend the Individual tier (if it’s just you). Likewise, for Incogni, I recommend Unlimited – because it adds custom data removal.

Pricing-wise, it’s a draw. Incogni becomes a few dollars cheaper than Cloaked when billed annually, so it wins on raw price. Its pricing page is also much clearer than Cloaked’s.

Incogni vs Cloaked: pros and cons

Each of these services has different real-world strengths and weaknesses. Here are my personal pros and cons for each:

Incogni’s pros:

• Automated data removal from 420+ data broker sites, plus 2,000+ others
• 30-day money-back guarantee
• Affordable annual pricing
• Leverages privacy laws for thorough data removal

Incogni’s cons:

• Lacks features beyond data removal requests and reporting
• The Android app is too basic
• Removal cycles may take longer due to formal privacy laws

Cloaked’s pros:

• Bundles several features on top of data removal
• Unlimited email/phone aliases
• $1 million identity theft insurance
• Several upcoming features announced

Cloaked’s cons:

• Covers much fewer data brokers than rivals
• Lacks custom removals
• Packs too many features into one service

Incogni vs Cloaked: future considerations and trends

Now that AI is a part of our daily lives, it significantly affects the privacy landscape. Large Language Models (LLMs) like OpenAI’s ChatGPT are now trained on human inputs – which may include personal info you gave during a conversation. Meanwhile, data brokers continue to tirelessly relist removed data.

According to Incogni’s blog, the company is expanding into AI data privacy research, while also increasing its broker count. It’s also working on creating a better mobile app. Cloaked notes in its changelog that it’s working on features like a VPN, “AI Defense”, and real-time data controls. It’s also expanding its alias and identity automation to virtual cards and eSIMs.

When you’re choosing a privacy service, I recommend you primarily look for a company that’s serious about recurring removals, and one that follows regulatory shifts like opt-out rights, and is aware of AI data use. Going forward, something like Cloaked’s “AI Defense” will be important – so that AI deals with AI, and you don’t have to.

Conclusion

All in all, both Incogni and Cloaked – while technically very different tools – share a common goal: to protect your sensitive online data. Which one is “best” depends on your use case, because both are recognized, high-quality data and identity protection services.

I recommend you think about your requirements, budget, and existing tools. If you need a pure data removal service – but not a stacked identity protection suite – then Incogni will do a professional job. Incogni is a transparent company that’s been around for many years now. On the other hand, if you don’t want to subscribe to separate security tools and have to worry about identity theft insurance – Cloaked is the better fit. According to a 2024 document from the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), data brokers hold information on hundreds of millions of Americans, so I recommend you seriously consider one of these services. You can always refer back to this guide to help you choose a privacy and data removal service.

---

Other reviews you might be interested in:

---

FAQ