We may earn affiliate commissions for the recommended products. Learn more.

VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access: which VPN is better?


VyprVPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) are versatile mid-tier VPN providers with different strengths. VyprVPN offers a speedy service under a small, well-maintained server fleet. PIA has thousands of servers yet needs to catch up in performance. But which VPN provider is a better option in 2024?

This review compares VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access to find the better overall provider. In search for our winner, we review their security and privacy capabilities, servers, locations, ease of use, speeds, torrenting, and streaming performance.

After thorough in-house testing, we have found our winner – VyprVPN. A hard-fought battle has proved that it is better than Private Internet Access in speed, customer support, usability, and pricing for the offered plans.

VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access VPN
⭐ Rating:
4.1
3.9
🥇 Overall rank:#13 out of #42#15 out of #42
🖥️ Servers:700 + servers in 64 countries30,000 + servers in 91 countries
📖 No logs policy:No logsNo logs
💵 Price:from $5.00/monthFrom $2.03/month
🔥 Coupons:VyprVPN coupon 50% OFFPIA coupon 83% OFF
🔒 VPN protocols:IKEv2, Chameleon, OpenVPNWireguard, OpenVPN, IKEv2/IPsec
🍿 Streaming services:Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, YouTubeNetflix, YouTube, Hulu, BBC iPlayer
🖥️ Platforms:Windows, Mac, Linux, Android, and iOSWindows, Mac, Linux, Android, iOS, Chrome, Firefox, Opera
📥 Simultaneous connections:30Unlimited
💁🏻 Support:Knowledge base, FAQs, 24/7 live chatKnowledge base, tickets, live chat

The speed of VyprVPN made the biggest difference in its victory against Private Internet Access. The provider uses the WireGuard protocol better than its competitor, plus its short-term subscription is cheaper. On top of that, VyprVPN offers 30 simultaneous connections, compared to PIA's 10.

Still, Private Internet Access is no pushover. It has more servers, additional features, and better streaming performance. However, aside from these strengths, VyprVPN wins or draws all the other tested categories.

Speed comparison: VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access

During in-house testing, we compared Private Internet Access vs VyprVPN and their speeds with the WireGuard protocol. To pick the better provider, we summed up the averages of test results across top locations, including three major regions: the US, the UK, and Canada. Here are the results:

  • Baseline: 450 Mbps download / 425 Mbps upload
VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
US224 Mbps / 303 Mbps108 Mbps / 60 Mbps
UK
309 Mbps / 314 Mbps223 Mbps / 86 Mbps
Canada228 Mbps / 309 Mbps125 Mbps / 31 Mbps

Let's start with the US. Here we can already see that VyprVPN is much faster than Private Internet Access. With downloads faster by 116 Mbps, it outperformed its competitor by 26%, which is a big difference. For uploads, the difference is even more apparent, where VyprVPN was faster by 67%.

Even in the UK, where Private Internet Access performed the best, the difference is clear: VyprVPN was 20% faster on downloads and 54% less on uploads.

For Canada, the same trend follows: Private Internet Access was 23% slower on downloads. For uploads, we have a massive difference: VyprVPN was 64% faster than its competitor.

We also tested the latency of connections to our main locations. Let's look at the results:

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
US102 ms108 ms
UK
37 ms36 ms
Canada113 ms115 ms

While the difference here is negligible, VyprVPN remains as the faster VPN provider. With low ping, it can be a solid VPN for gaming.

Wrapping up
With such a decisive victory in major tested categories, we see that, on average, VyprVPN was 43% faster than Private Internet Access.

Netflix and streaming performance

Comparing VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access and their streaming capabilities, both options are suitable for accessing Netflix and other major platforms. While not as good as our top VPNs for streaming, both providers accessed US Netflix library. However, VyprVPN has a slight edge, as it also unlocks the German Netflix library.

Still, if streaming performance is your top priority, Private Internet Access may be a better choice because it has more servers. VyprVPN only has 700 servers in 64 locations, and if many users connect to the same server, it becomes overcrowded and unstable. With more options, Private Internet Access is a better choice for streaming without buffering.

For other streaming platforms, both options unlock YouTube and Hulu. However, VyprVPN is better because it accessed BBC iPlayer, which PIA failed to do.

Still, Private Internet Access has one more advantage over VyprVPN – a Smart DNS feature. It allows users to unblock streaming platforms with devices that do not support VPN apps. While VyprVPN does not have this feature, both providers have apps for routers. They route the entire internet connection through a VPN server, which means all connected streaming devices will be affected as well.

Wrapping up
While VyprVPN does a better job at unblocking streaming libraries, a larger server fleet helps Private Internet Access avoid overcrowded servers. Both providers are solid VPNs for streaming, but PIA is our winner due to more locations and a Smart DNS feature.

Torrenting

Because torrenting is one of the main reasons to get a VPN, we review VyprVPN and Private Internet Access in their support for P2P communication.

First, we are happy to see that both providers have a kill switch and leak protection tools for safe torrenting. However, VyprVPN had restrictions for P2P connections in the past. Right now, its servers support torrenting, but the speeds stay capped at 5MB/s.

Private Internet Access has a big advantage over its opponent. It is a great VPN for torrenting because it has a split tunneling feature, and all Private Internet Access servers support P2P communication.

Wrapping up
Private Internet Access is a better VPN provider for torrenting because it does not throttle speeds, all of its servers support P2P communication, and it has the necessary tools for leak protection.
VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Stealth VPN✅Yes✅Yes
Kill switch✅Yes✅Yes
Split tunneling✅Yes✅Yes
Web filters✅Yes✅Yes

As we observe and compare VyprVPN vs PIA And their features, both options have essential VPN tools, but which provider offers more?

The table above shows that Private Internet Access has a slight edge because it includes a Smart DNS feature. It is an essential tool for streaming because it unblocks new streaming libraries for devices that do not support VPN apps, such as older versions of Apple TV, Amazon Fire Stick, Chromecast, and others.

Still, just because the number of features is bigger does not mean that the effect of all tools combined is smaller. Let's look at the offered essentials before picking our winner.

Stealth VPN

Also known as server obfuscation, Stealth VPNs try to make VPN connections indistinguishable from regular web traffic. It lets us browse the web freely in countries like China or Iran and stay undetected, and VyprVPN has the right tool for the job. Its Stealth VPN, called Chameleon, avoids spying attempts with constant IP changes.

Private Internet Access also has a Stealth VPN feature that uses multi-hopping and obfuscation to keep connections invisible in restrictive regions. With it, PIA VPN bypasses firewalls and avoids internet censorship or punishment from government agencies.

Kill switch

A must-have tool for every provider, both VyprVPN and Private Internet Access have a kill switch to cut the internet connection if the contact with the VPN server is lost and prevent data leaks.

VyprVPN kill switch can be accessed in the connection settings tab. The user can choose between an application-level or a system-level kill switch, which will deny internet access until you connect to a VPN server.

vyprvpn kill switch settings

Private Internet Access kill switch also has two modes: basic and advanced, which do the same things as their counterparts. It can be accessed in the privacy settings that are visible on the sidebar of the app.

PIA kill switch

Other features

Private Internet Access also has a split tunneling feature in the networking section where the user can set up its rules. All we need to do is select the programs that bypass VPN tunneling to fully control internet access.

PIA split tunneling

VyprVPN also has a split tunneling feature, but it is unavailable on Windows devices.

vyprvpn split tunneling

Smart DNS lets you change the geolocation of devices that do not support VPN apps, and Private Internet Access offers step-by-step tutorials to set everything up. The provider ensures that even users with little technical knowledge can use their devices and watch remote streaming libraries.

Unfortunately, VyprVPN does not have a Smart DNS tool, which is a shame because it is a very useful feature for clients with older TVs and streaming devices, but it has a router app to affect all connected gadgets.

Wrapping up
Because both PIA and VyprVPN go toe-to-toe in terms of features, and each option has its set of strengths, with no clear winner we declare a draw

VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access: which is more secure?

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
EncryptionAES-256AES-128 and AES-256
HashSHA-256SHA-512
RAM serversNoYes
A member of the Fourteen Eyes Alliance?NoYes
No-logs policyIndependently AuditedIndependently Audited
Kill switchYesYes
Ad blockerYesYes
DNS leak protectionYesYes

To choose the better provider for security and privacy, we compared VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access and their tools for safety. For this category, we tested and analyzed their encryption protocols, privacy policies, essential features, and their base location.

Wrapping up
Again, the battle is very close: Private Internet Access offers a better infrastructure with RAM-only servers. However, it is based in the United States – one of the worst locations for user privacy and the key country in the Fourteen Eyes Alliance. VyprVPN does not have RAM-only servers, but the company is registered in Switzerland, which has much better digital privacy laws. Without a clear winner, we declare a draw.

Infrastructure

At first, Private Internet Access seems like our winner because it uses diskless servers, while VyprVPN does not have RAM-only options. Paired with the network size, 30000 servers in 91 countries, Private Internet Access covers more territory than its competitor. However, while VyprVPN only has 700 servers, it owns all of them, which makes its infrastructure safer than Private Internet Access.

Both providers use top-quality AES-256 encryption, but Private Internet Access lets you choose a lighter but less secure AES-128 standard. They also share support for OpenVPN and WireGuard protocols, but PIA includes IKEv2 versus VyprVPN's IPsec and Chameleon.

Privacy

Private Internet Access is a less private option because it is based in the United States, which puts all users under threat of government surveillance. VyprVPN is a better option because Switzerland is one of the best VPN countries with favorable privacy laws.

Logging

VyprVPN follows an independently audited no-logs policy that promises not to collect information about user connections. Private Internet Access also abides by court-proven policy to not log client information. VyprVPN was tested in 2018 by Leviathan Security, while Private Internet Access has been audited by Deloitte. Both auditing firms have proven the fact that these VPN services do not keep any logs.

Plans and pricing

When comparing available subscriptions and their prices, we look for affordable options that bring the most value for your money. VPN providers offer simple services where the features never change, but users can save money with longer commitments.

PlanVyprVpnPrivate Internet Access
Monthly$10.00/month$11.99/month
One year$5.00/month$3.33/month
Three years + three months$2.03/month
Check VyprVPN discountsCheck PIA Discounts

If you want a short deal, VyprVPN is a better choice. Its monthly subscription costs $10.00/month, compared to PIA's $11.99/month.

The second-tier subscription of Private Internet Access costs 3.33 for one year. It is better than VyprVPN, as its next-level deal is its last, and longest subscription is more expensive – $5.00/month.

Where VyprVPN has no more options, PIA’s ultimate deal only costs $2.03/month. Its only downside is a long commitment: the deal lasts for 3 years and 3 months.

VyprVPN has a 3-day free trial for mobile devices, while PIA offers a 7-day free trial for iOS and Android apps. Users can also pay for both Private Internet Access and VyprVPN and get a refund via a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Wrapping up
With plans and pricing, Private Internet Access is a better option because its plans let you save more money. VyprVPN is only slightly cheaper for monthly subscriptions, but ends up costing more in long-term deals.

Servers and Locations

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Servers700+Thousands of servers
Countries (total)64+91+
Virtual locationsNoNo
Dedicated IPsNoYes

While both providers offer a great server infrastructure, Private Internet Access has more servers and broader global coverage. With 30000+ servers in 91 locations, it is bigger and better than VyprVPN, which only has 700+ servers in 64 countries.

Still, VyprVPN owns all of its servers. Private Internet Access might have a clear number advantage, but because it only rents the data centers where the hardware it stored, the provider has less control over their protection.

Wrapping up
While Private Internet Access has more servers and covers more countries, it does not fully own its servers like VyprVPN, but they run on diskless, RAM-only servers. Still, a much larger server fleet and global coverage make Private Internet Access the winner of this category.

Platforms, interface and ease of use

VyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Supported OSWindows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, Mac, Linux, Android, iOS
Other software and devicesAndroid TV, Fire devices, KodiAndroid TV, Fire devices, Kodi
Browser extensionsChrome, Firefox
Simultaneous connections3010
Usability levelEasy to set upEasy to set up

VPN services and apps need to be compatible with major devices and platforms. We are happy to see that both Private Internet Access and VyprVPN work on main operating systems – Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, and iOS.

Apart from available OS, our providers get bonus points for available browser extensions. Private Internet Access add-ons work on Chrome and Firefox, while VyprVPN does not have one.

For other devices, Private Internet Access works well with Android TV, Fire devices and Kodi, and VyprVPN also works with routers, Blackphone, QNAP, and Anonabox.

If we focus on the usability of platforms, VyprVPN supports 30 parallel connections, which is a lot more than PIA's Unlimited simultaneous devices.

Wrapping up
While Private Internet Access is a strong contender that has browser extensions, VyprVPN is a better provider with stable support across all platforms and 30 simultaneous connections.

Desktop apps

VyprVPN has a simple and comfortable user interface for desktop apps. On the bottom, we have three main segments for adjustments and customization.

vyprvpn app

Visually, the macOS app is near identical. However, VyprVPN is a rare gem for Apple users, as it comes with a better macOS program than Windows. It includes a split tunneling feature that is missing for other operating systems. This addition makes VyprVPN one of the best VPNs for Mac.

For Linux, we are back to mediocrity – a terminal-based VPN app that is only adapted for Ubuntu and Linux Mint distributions.

Private Internet Access comes with a dark-themed vertical GUI, which is identical on both Windows and Mac. The main window shows the country and the IP of the VPN server and an option to expand the window to see more.

pia windows interface

PIA's has an intuitive Linux app with a menu bar that is easy to understand and navigate.

PIA Linux app

Mobile apps

Private Internet Access has two identical apps for mobile devices with a very similar layout to its desktop versions. They are easy to use and navigate, even for beginner users.

pia android interface

VyprVPN's Android app delivers the best product with unique extra features. It comes with public wifi protection tool and customizable DNS settings.

android customize vyprvpn

However, with iOS, its mobile version gets worse. The main package loses two important features: a kill switch and split tunneling options.

Customer support

VyprVPNPIA
24/7 live chat

Email

Phone line
Guides or articles

FAQs

Regarding customer support, both VyprVPN and Private Internet Access provide effective help and quick solutions.They offer informative guides and tutorials, FAQs, and maintain user forums. Most importantly, both providers help clients with a live chat option.

With live chat as the most popular way to seek help, VyprVPN has an advantage because of its 24/7 availability. Private Internet Access’ live chat is only available during work hours.

Wrapping up
While both providers have the most effective customer support solutions, VyprVPN is better because of its 24/7 live chat option.

VyprVPN vs Private Internet Access – which one wins?

CategoryVyprVPNPrivate Internet Access
Protection
Speed
Features
Price
Platforms
Customer support
Streaming
Torrenting
Server locations

While the battle was close, VyprVPN is better than Private Internet Access, and the winner of our comparison.

Private Internet Access showed better results in server locations, torrenting, and VPN features, it was not enough to beat its competitor. VyprVPN was much faster, had more intuitive apps, and offered more simultaneous connections. On top of that, it had cheaper short-term deals and more customer support options.

Still, Private Internet Access is no pushover. As we tested privacy and security capabilities plus streaming performance, their results were not decisive enough to declare a winner. All things considered, VyprVPN had to win other categories to be better than Private Internet Access and earn this close but deserved victory.

FAQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are markedmarked