Georgia man hands over car and cash after being catfished using AI
A fraud case with many twists and turns.

A romantic outgoing call, only incoming on a phone beside it. Image by Cybernews.
- A Georgia man believed he was engaged to a fake woman posing as a Florida deputy.
- Police say Caleb Mills used stolen photos, fake accounts, AI, and voice-changing tools to build trust.
- The victim gave money and exchanged vehicles before police linked the fake identity to Mills.
- Police say Mills may have targeted victims across multiple states and asked others affected to come forward.
Key Takeaways by nexos.ai, reviewed by Cybernews staff.
A Georgia man reportedly spent months believing he was engaged to “Hailey Morello,” a woman he had never met face-to-face, and believed she was a Florida sheriff’s deputy.
Caleb Mills, 25, is accused of creating the fictional identity using stolen photographs of a real female deputy, fake accounts, multiple telephone numbers, artificial intelligence, and voice-changing technology.
The Athens-Clarke County Police Department said Mills allegedly used photos from women's social media accounts to lure his victims and build trust.
Police say Mills used the identities “to establish online relationships with victims” across multiple states.
The victim in this particular case was so emotionally invested that he believed he was engaged to “Hailey,” under the illusion that she was his genuine romantic partner.
Police say the victim gave Mills money and exchanged vehicles with him, turning what looked like an online romance into an alleged financial fraud.
The family tried to expose the catfish
The victim's family became increasingly suspicious that he was being catfished, so they decided to intervene and contact “Hailey.”
In a bizarre twist, instead of ending the relationship, Mills decided to file a harassment complaint against the family, escalating circumstances even further.
Police were able to establish that “Hailey” hadn’t made a complaint at all, and that, moreover, Mills had also been posing as “Alex Morello,” a relative of “Hailey,” to make matters seem more plausible to the victim.
In a kind of “sting trap,” the police advised the victim to call his “fiancée’s” phone, and while in the company of Mills, the name “Hubbs” flashed up on the screen. Mills had been caught in broad daylight.
Has your password leaked?
The defendant had more victims
Mills was arrested on July 20th on an array of charges. These include identity fraud, impersonation of a police officer, and false statements.
The defendant may have continued fraudulent activity after being released on bond, although that remains an allegation, and further charges could follow, reported People.
The Athens-Clarke County Police Department went on record warning that “technology and artificial intelligence continue to evolve,” adding that scams, along with catfishing, are becoming “increasingly sophisticated.”
Police have asked anyone affected by this and other scams to step forward, as they seek justice for such deceptive acts.