We may earn affiliate commissions for the recommended products. Learn more.

TorGuard vs Private Internet Access (PIA): which VPN is better?


TorGuard VPN and Private Internet Access are two evenly-matched VPN providers. Both offer plenty of servers, have good speeds, and protect users with advanced security. But which VPN is ultimately better?

Despite being similar on paper, there are bound to be some differences between the two VPNs. So we’ve conducted a series of thorough tests to dive into the details and compare the features, speed, streaming, security, value for money, and other factors of the two VPNs.

Spoiler warning: Private Internet Access VPN wins! But that’s not the entire story – read on to get the full lowdown on why we chose Private Internet Access as the best VPN in this comparison review.

TorGuard vs Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access stats are far more impressive (30000+ servers in 91 countries) compared to TorGuard VPN’s 3000+ servers in 50 countries. While TorGuard VPN unblocked YouTube only, PIA also effortlessly accessed Netflix and Hulu. Private Internet Access also gives you more simultaneous connections and is almost half the price of its competitor. Taking all this into account, Private Internet Access provides better value for the money you pay.

Private Internet Access VPNTorGuard
⭐ Rating:
3.9
3.6
🥇 Overall rank:#15 out of #42#22 out of #42
🖥️ Servers:30,000 + servers in 91 countries3,000 + servers in 50 countries
📖 No logs policy:No logsNo logs
💵 Price:From $2.03/monthfrom $4.00/month
🔥 Coupons:PIA coupon 83% OFFTorGuard coupon 50% OFF
🔒 VPN protocols:Wireguard, OpenVPN, IKEv2/IPsecWireGuard, OpenVPN, OpenConnect
🍿 Streaming services:Netflix, YouTube, Hulu, BBC iPlayerYoutube
🖥️ Platforms:Windows, Mac, Linux, Android, iOS, Chrome, Firefox, OperaWindows, Mac, Linux, Android, iOS
📥 Simultaneous connections:Unlimited8
💁🏻 Support:Knowledge base, tickets, live chatTicket, email, support center

Netflix and streaming performance

PlatformPrivate Internet AccessTorGuard
Netflix✅ Yes❌ No
Hulu✅ Yes❌ No
YouTube✅ Yes✅ Yes
Amazon Prime Video❌ No❌ No
BBC iPlayer❌ No❌ No

While neither of the services could go on the list of the best streaming VPNs, Private Internet Access VPN is capable of bypassing geo-restrictions on more streaming platforms than TorGuard VPN.

Starting from Private Internet Access VPN, it easily unblocks Netflix US and Hulu with its US servers. It can be slow at times, but we still accessed both sites. It’s also able to unblock geo-restricted YouTube videos. That said, Private Internet Access VPN didn't bypass geo-blocks on BBC iPlayer and Amazon Prime Video.

On the other hand, TorGuard VPN performs much worse. We consistently failed to access Hulu, Netflix, BBC iPlayer, or even Amazon Prime Video. The only service we could watch was YouTube. However, TorGuard VPN does offer dedicated streaming servers, which could fare better, but you have to pay a considerable extra fee ($21.98/month).

Wrapping up:
While both VPNs can’t access too many streaming platforms, Private Internet Access VPN unblocked more streaming platforms than TorGuard VPN. The latter could only access YouTube, while Private Internet Access bypassed restrictions on Netflix and Hulu as well.

Plans & pricing

Like with most VPNs, the prices of both TorGuard VPN and Private Internet Access VPN depend on the billing term you choose. The longer you purchase the service for, the less per month you’ll have to pay.

PlanPrivate Internet AccessTorGuard
One month$11.99$9.99
Six months$7.50/month$6.66/month
One year$3.33/month$4.00/month
Two years$2.03/month
Get PIA DiscountsGet VPN Discounts

In any case, Private Internet Access VPN offers much better value for the money you pay. While TorGuard VPN is cheaper in terms of short-term options, Private Internet Access VPN is a better pick for long-term deals. Its one-year deal is only $3.33/month, while TorGuard VPN is $4.00/month. Private Internet Access also offers a two-year plan for only $2.03/month.

Private Internet Access VPN also offers 10 simultaneous connections compared to TorGuard VPN’s 8 device connections, so it’s better for sharing with your family.

In terms of refunds, Private Internet Access VPN provides the standard 30-day money-back guarantee window. Meanwhile, TorGuard VPN only gives you 7-days to claim a refund should you change your mind.

One factor in TorGuard VPN’s favor is the free trial, but don’t get too excited yet – signing up for this is a strangely convoluted process. To qualify for the free version, you have to join a different VPN provider and then send TorGuard VPN proof of your last bill. Once this has been checked, TorGuard VPN will permit access to its 7-day free trial.

Wrapping up:
Private Internet Access is cheaper than TorGuard VPN in terms of long-term subscriptions. Plus, it provides more simultaneous connections (10) and a longer, 30-day money-back guarantee.

TorGuard vs Private Internet Access: which is more secure?

Private Internet AccessTorGuard
EncryptionAES-256 and ChaCha20AES-256
HashSHA-512SHA-512
RAM serversYesYes
A member of the 5-Eyes, 9-Eyes, or 14-Eyes AllianceYesYes
No-logs policyAuditedNot audited
Kill switchYesYes
Ad blockersYesYes
DNS leak protectionNoYes

Like all top VPNs, TorGuard VPN and Private Internet Access protect their users with robust security capable of warding off digital threats. Features like AES-256 encryption and a kill switch are a given, but which provider goes the extra mile?

Infrastructure

You can trust your data is safe when a VPN operates with RAM-only servers. They’re built in a way that your data gets erased after every reboot. This protects against security breaches and confirms that your data isn’t being collected or stored.

The good news is that both Private Internet Access VPN and TorGuard VPN use RAM-only servers. Neither of the providers will ever keep your information, nor can it be stolen, as the servers are regularly wiped.

Privacy

TorGuard VPN and Private Internet Access protect you with the gold-standard AES-256 encryption. Trusted by banks, governments, and the military, not even brute-force attacks can penetrate its defenses.

However, both providers also give you the option of selecting AES-128 level encryption. This is useful if you’re using a low-spec device as it uses less resources and is faster.

Here’s the tricky part – Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN are both based in the US, a key nation in the 5-Eyes alliance initiative. The United States has a notoriously intrusive stance on privacy issues. In theory, authorities could demand to see user data.

That is undoubtedly a concern, but luckily, both VPNs we’re reviewing today have RAM-only servers that are routinely wiped. So even if the US government does request user info, there would be nothing to hand over.

Logging

Private Internet Access VPN and TorGuard VPN have strict no-logging policies, but only Private Internet Access VPN backs this up with an independent audit. Third-party audits involve an outside body thoroughly checking the policies of a specific VPN, and Private Internet Access was proven to not log or store user data. Hopefully, TorGuard VPN will follow suit and put its service to the test soon, but currently, we can only go on its word.

Wrapping up:
While both VPNs have their ups and downs, Private Internet Access VPN has undergone an independent audit to verify its no-logs policy, which gives it the edge.

TorGuard vs PIA: speed comparison

In case you didn’t know, no matter what VPN you use – it can slightly slow down your Internet. That’s because it reroutes your traffic into a remote server, which always leads to a decrease in speeds.

However, the best VPNs use advanced tunneling protocols to improve performance and render slowdown as minimal as possible. The premier protocol on the market is WireGuard (or its modern variations), and it's used by both Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN.

So, to compare both provider’s speeds, we conducted some tests on a selection of servers to see which was faster:

  • Baseline: 300 Mbps download/300 Mbps upload
WireGuard (Download/Upload speed)Private Internet AccessTorGuard
US110 Mbps/168 Mbps272Mbps/239 Mbps
UK140 Mbps/222 Mbps217Mbps/275 Mbps
Switzerland294 Mbps/254 Mbps292Mbps/271 Mbps

TorGuard VPN is generally faster than Private Internet Access VPN. That’s not to say it's perfect, as we did encounter some connection issues along the way. But overall, it’s a faster VPN.

TorGuard VPN managed to retain around 86% of initial connection speeds. Meanwhile, Private Internet Access retained only around 60% of initial speeds on average.

However, Private Internet Access has thousands more servers. And the best way to get a faster connection while using a VPN is by picking a server that’s closest to your location. So depending on where you live, you may get more options with Private Internet Access.

Wrapping up
TorGuard VPN is definitely faster than Private Internet Access. Its speed reduction rate was around 14% compared to PIA VPN’s 40%.

Features overview

Aside from the basics, a premium VPN will include useful features to make it worth the download. Let’s look at what kind of benefits you can expect with Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN.

Split tunneling

If you want to keep some apps off the VPN connection (like your local work email client), split tunneling is the feature you’re looking for. This clever setting enables you to choose which apps you want to run through the VPN and which don’t.

split tunneling pia

Private Internet Access provides split tunneling on Android, Linux, macOS, and Windows, but TorGuard VPN only has the feature on its Android app.

Proxy

If you’d like an extra level of privacy when using a VPN, a proxy will redirect your connection to a new location. If you ever find your VPN is being blocked by a firewall, a proxy is the quick solution.

pia socks5

Private Internet Access gives you the Shadowsocks and SOCKS5 proxies, TorGuard VPN includes the latter and a super-secure Stealth proxy which disguises your VPN use as regular traffic.

Port forwarding

Port forwarding is an advanced VPN feature for remotely connecting to other devices. It’s useful for torrenting and setting up gaming servers.

Both Torguard VPN and Private Internet Access offer this feature, but you need a bit of tech knowhow to use it. It’s also worth noting that PIA’s was slightly harder to configure than TorGuard VPN.

Ad blocker

Ad blockers are handy features that improve your online activity by banishing annoying adverts and pop-ups.

Private Internet Access’s ad-blocker is called MACE. It blocks DNS, so banners and adverts will be a thing of the past. It even works on YouTube adverts. MACE also works as a general protection suite, as it blocks malicious websites.

pia mace

TorGuard VPN’s ad blocker is the same. It’s a DNS-blocking tool that will get rid of irritating adverts online.

Kill switch

With a reliable kill switch switched on, your anonymity is safe when you’re on unstable connections, like public wifi.

TorGuard VPN’s built-in kill switch instantly turns your Internet connection off if the VPN unexpectedly crashes. This VPN also has an App Kill feature which allows you to customize which apps you want to be killed if your VPN connection drops.

Torguard VPN app kill 1

PIA’s kill switch is just as reliable – it kicks in the second your VPN connection fails.

Wrapping up:
Both Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN have a robust selection of high-quality features, including a market-standard kill switch, port forwarding, proxies, ad blockers, and more.

Server locations

Private Internet AccessTorGuard
Servers30000+3000+
Countries (total)9150
Virtual locationsYesNo
Specialty serversNoNo

Not many VPNs can compete with PIA's servers, and TorGuard VPN is no exception. Private Internet Access blows its rivals away with a whopping 30000+ servers across 91 countries.

Those servers are dotted around Europe, North America, South America, Asia, Australasia, and Africa. It’s a huge selection that will cover all your VPN server requirements.

To be fair on TorGuard VPN, it would fare well in a server face-off against any other VPN. Its fleet consists of 3000 servers in 50 countries, which is very respectable.

Wrapping up:
TorGuard VPN has an above-average server count of 3000, but Private Internet Access has the biggest server fleet of any VPN we’ve ever tested (30000+ servers across 91 countries).

Torrenting

TorGuard VPN and Private Internet Access VPN are decent VPNs for torrenting, but which provider is more suitable for it? To find the answer, let’s look at the features.

Private Internet Access supports P2P file sharing on all of its 30000 servers. You can also use Shadowsocks and SOCKS5 proxies to hide your IP address and divert traffic.

Surprisingly, despite being a relatively slower VPN, its torrent speeds were excellent. Our tests hit the 10-15 MB/s mark, so your downloads will move at pace.

TorGuard VPN also supports P2P file sharing and offers the SOCKS5 proxy. Meanwhile, its speeds varied between the 10MB/s – 6MB/s mark.

Wrapping up:
PIA’s vast server selection and slightly better torrenting speed makes it a better VPN alternative for torrenting.

Platforms, interface, and ease of use

TorGuardPrivate Internet Access
Supported OSWindows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, Mac, Linux, Android, iOS,
Browser extensionsChrome, FirefoxChrome, Firefox, Brave, Edge, Opera
Other devicesKodi, Android TV,Amazon Fire devicesAndroid TV, Fire devices
Simultaneous connections810

Private Internet Access VPN and TorGuard VPN both cover the main platforms (Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, and Linux) with dedicated apps. However, Private Internet access offers more browser extensions and offers 10 simultaneous connections on a single subscription – two more than TorGuard VPN.

Wrapping up:
Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN provide apps for the usual devices, but PIA supports more simultaneous connections and offers more browser extensions.

Desktop apps

PIA's Windows app is easy to navigate and user-friendly. The app's main dashboard shows your connection status and an on/off button.

pia windows app interface

You can also easily find other details like protocol, cipher, and encryption information. The general layout is slick and attractive. The macOS and Linux apps are mostly the same – nice to look at and simple to get around.

TorGuard VPN’s Windows, macOS, and Linux apps are also very similar. However, they’re not as easy to use as Private Internet Access and are more suited to users already familiar with VPNs. The interface is not as eye-catching and looks dated compared to Private Internet Access. There’s no visible map to show servers – you have to choose a connection from a list.

Mobile apps

Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN’s mobile apps are pretty similar to the desktop versions in terms of features and appearance.

pia android UI

Meanwhile, it’s worth noting that there are some differences between TorGuard VPN’s mobile apps. For starters, you can only use split tunneling on Android. Plus, the protocols vary depending on the OS – Android has OpenVPN and WireGuard, while iOS has OpenVPN and IKEv2/IPSec.

torguard android

Either way, the overall experience is much more simple than with TorGuard VPN’s desktop apps.

Customer support

Private Internet AccessTorGuard
24/7 live chat
Email
Phone line
Articles and guides
FAQs

If you’re experiencing problems with your VPN, both Private Internet Access and TorGuard VPN offer multiple customer support options to give you a helping hand.

Private Internet Access offers live chat, email, and an extensive knowledge base with guides, tutorials, and FAQs.

TorGuard VPN claims to have 24/7 support, but disappointingly, there’s no live chat. This means you’ll need to raise a ticket or reach out via email. The good news is that responses are usually very swift.

TorGuard VPN also has a knowledge base with setup guides and FAQs, and a forum for fellow users to discuss the service.

Wrapping up:
Private Internet Access offers more customer support options than TorGuard VPN. This includes a 24/7 live chat which is usually the fastest way to reach support.

TorGuard vs Private Internet Access (PIA) – which one wins?

CategoryPIATorGuard
Speed
Features
Streaming
Protection
Torrenting
Price
Server locations
Ease of use
Customer support

Overall, Private Internet Access is a better VPN than TorGuard VPN. It’s stronger and has more features than the competitor. Plus, it boasts the largest server fleet we’ve ever seen and is the more convenient option for unblocking streaming content.

That being said, TorGuard is not a poor VPN. It offers great download and upload speed retention rates and includes all the essential security features in its packages. Plus, it even offers a free 7-day trial.

Overall, Private Internet Access wins the Private Internet Access vs TorGuard VPN comparison hands down due to its streaming capabilities, security measures, price, and more.

FAQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are markedmarked