Incogni vs Aura: which privacy tool should you choose in 2026?
Being behind major reports like The Mother of All Breaches and RockYou2024, our in-house cybersecurity experts and journalists provide unbiased, real-world testing and in-depth analysis.
We maintain complete transparency by openly sharing our testing methodologies with our audience.
Learn more
In 2025, identity theft remains one of the most popular cybercrimes, with the Federal Trade Commission receiving over 1.1 million reports the previous year. Online privacy protection services, Incogni and Aura, combat this trend by finding and removing personal information on data brokers and people search sites.
As an information security expert, I have scrutinized both services extensively. Working with Cybernews researchers, we ran Incogni for a month to assess its performance and also tested Aura for an in-depth Incogni vs Aura comparison. To help you choose between these services, I compare their security features, plans, and pricing, and additional benefits. I also evaluate Aura’s broader data protection capabilities, highlight other Incogni features and compare my analysis with expert findings and real user experiences.
Incogni is the clear winner if your priority is removing personal data from as many databases as possible. Its verified 420+ broker coverage, automated follow-ups, and strong track record of successful removals make it the most effective choice for users focused on data erasure. Aura is a solid option if you also want identity theft protection, insurance, and a generous trial.
Incogni vs Aura overview
| Incogni | Aura | |
| Rating | 5 | 4.4 |
| Overall rank | #1 out of 5 data removal tools | #4 out of 5 data removal tools |
| Price | From $7.19/month (with a code CYBERNEWS55) | From $8.00/month |
| Number of site removals | 2420+ with custom removals | 130 |
| Privacy reports | ✅ Yes, monthly | ❌ No |
| Custom removal requests | ✅ Yes | ❌ No |
| Free trial | ❌ No | ✅ Yes, 14 days |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 60 days |
| Geographical availability | US, Canada, UK, EU (plus Norway, Switzerland, Iceland, Liechtenstein, Isle of Man)” | United States, Canada, U.K., Germany, France |
| Customer support | 24/7 live chat and email support, with phone support (Unlimited and Family Unlimited plans) | 24/7/365 phone and email support, live chat, online help center |
| Primary focus | Automated removal of personal data from data brokers, people-search sites, and other public databases | All-in-one identity theft, credit, and online security protection |
| Best suited for | Private users who want hands-off, recurring data broker removals without a full security bundle | Families looking for a full digital safety bundle (identity theft, credit monitoring, and device protection) |
The Cybernews team consists of professional and highly skilled writers and an in-house research team. They’re the core of all our reviews, bringing the performance of each tool closer to you. Additionally, we stick to a transparent testing process, which includes investigating various services, their features, and disclosing our testing methodology with everyone. Discover more about our testing process.
How we test data removal services
At Cybernews, we follow strict research and testing standards when reviewing privacy tools. For this Aura vs Incogni comparison, I exclusively used our privacy tools testing framework to ensure accuracy and transparency.
- Features and scope (40%). I evaluated how well each service performs at locating and removing personal data from brokers and people-search sites. I also considered extra features, such as identity theft insurance, real-time monitoring, and automated follow-ups, to understand the full scope of each tool’s protection.
- Pricing and value (25%). I compared subscription plans, free trials, and money-back guarantees against the range of benefits offered. The service that delivers strong data protection and extra perks at a reasonable price scored higher in this category.
- Security and compliance (20%). I examined how each platform handles sensitive data, including its use of encryption, storage policies, and adherence to privacy laws like GDPR and CCPA. I also took independent audits and assurances, such as ISAE 3000 certifications, into account.
- Ease of use (15%). I tested how intuitive each product is, from setup and dashboard navigation to managing removal requests.
About Incogni
Incogni is a data removal tool released in 2021. It was developed by cybersecurity experts at Surfshark, who also created one of the best VPNs, antivirus software, and private search engine. Notably, Incogni is the first data removal service to undergo an independent Deloitte assessment, highlighting its commitment to verified and trustworthy data protection practices.
Incogni protects users by searching for their personal information on 420+ data brokers' websites. Such sites can hold your full name, phone number, email, home address, employment details, and more. Cybercriminals use this data for investment fraud, impersonation, and phishing.
One of the major benefits of Incogni is that it automatically sends data removal requests. Contacting dozens of data brokers manually is time-consuming and does not guarantee that they will not reupload your data in the future. To help close the gaps automated removals can miss, Incogni introduced its Custom Removals feature in 2025. This feature allows you to submit URLs that aren’t in its automated broker list for human-assisted takedown by Incogni’s privacy specialists. This way, you also receive more personalized support from the team.
Incogni has a team of privacy experts that compel such sites to remove personal data based on GDPR, CCPA, and PIPEDA privacy protection laws. It also has suppression lists, which means that selected data brokers are prohibited from reuploading your data or face legal action.
About Aura
Aura is a comprehensive cybersecurity service that dates back to 2017, when it was known as iSubscribed. In 2019, it rebranded as Aura and is now rated among the best identity theft protection services by us and several other expert tech review sites.
What I value most is Aura’s broad data security scope. It offers up to $1 million identity theft insurance per person, 3-credit bureau monitoring, financial transaction alerts, a VPN, antivirus, password manager, and more.
It also has an identical feature to Incogni for scouting data broker websites and removing personal information. However, it covers only “140+”, which is significantly fewer than Incogni. Aura is more focused on data removal from US brokers, while Incogni also covers Canada and European countries.
Incogni vs Aura: features comparison
Picking between Aura vs Incogni is easier when you compare their features side by side. Take a look at the table below to see what each offers.
| Incogni | Aura | |
| Data broker removal: | 420+ (2420+ with custom removals) sites | 140+ |
| Identity theft protection: | Limited to data removal | Comprehensive identity theft protection |
| Antivirus and VPN: | Included with Surfshark One+ bundle | Included on all plans |
| Real-time alerts and monitoring: | Yes, daily data removal alerts and reports | Yes, daily data removal monitoring and monthly reports |
| Automation level: | Automatic data removal requests | Automatic data removal requests |
Incogni and Aura take different approaches to online privacy protection, with Incogni having a slight edge. It targets nearly three times as many data broker sites as Aura, it’s also available in more countries, and costs less.
Aura, on the other hand, excels as an all-encompassing digital identity protection tool. Alongside data broker sites, it also monitors three credit bureaus, offers identity theft insurance, a VPN, antivirus, and other valuable cybersecurity benefits.
Incogni offers similar features if you choose the Surfshark One+ bundle. It’s worth noting here that during my tests, Surfshark VPN performed better than Aura VPN. However, because Aura offers significantly more cybersecurity features, it wins this round.
Incogni vs. Aura: pricing and plans
Let's also compare Incogni vs Aura plans and pricing side-by-side:
| Plan | Incogni | Aura |
| Individual (monthly) | $15.98/month | $9.00/month |
| Couple (monthly) | – | $17.00/month |
| Family (monthly) | $31.98/month | $20.00/month |
| Individual (yearly plan) | $95.88 or $7.19/month (with a code CYBERNEWS55) | $120 or $10/month |
| Individual Unlimited (yearly plan) | $179.88 or $14.99/month | – |
| Couple (yearly plan) | – | $180 or $18/month |
| Family (yearly plan) | $191.88 or $15.99/month | $290 or $29/month |
| Family Unlimited (yearly plan) | $275.88 or $22.99/month | – |
| Free trial | No | 14 days |
| Money back guarantee | 30 days | 60 days |
Both services' plans are quite similar, with Incogni offering better prices on most plans.
Incogni’s family plan is more affordable. Its annual individual and family plans also cost less — the latter being nearly $100 cheaper in comparison.
Unlike Incogni, Aura also offers a 14-day free trial, and its money-back guarantee is valid for twice as long.
Considering that Aura offers many additional benefits, it may be a better choice for individuals and families that require multiple cybersecurity tools. Incogni subscription is best for data removal, as it targets three times more data broker sites at a more affordable cost. You can also get Incogni with some of the additional privacy tools that Aura offers by opting for the Surfshark One+ bundle.
Incogni vs Aura: security
Cybersecurity professionals developed both Incogni and Aura, and I can verify that both services keep your data safe. Firstly, both use AES-256 encryption, which is the current security standard in the software industry. However, Incogni uses AES-256-GCM mode of operation, which also verifies the authenticity and integrity of data.
It's worth noting that Aura does not disclose the exact mode of operation of its encryption. Although it is likely just as advanced as Incogni's, the latter is more transparent about its data security features. You will also notice that Incogni keeps personal data gathering to a minimum, primarily to process payments and maintain the service.
Aura, on the other hand, is more liberal regarding data sharing. For example, its privacy policy states that it can use your data to "advance our or a third party's legitimate interests." While this is nothing extraordinary in digital marketing, it is detrimental to online privacy protection.
Both services also align with GDPR, CCPA, and PIPEDA privacy regulations. They are also both based in the 9-eyes countries (Aura – US, Incogni – Netherlands). Due to Incogni’s more restricted and transparent data collection and sharing, it also wins in this section.
Incogni vs Aura: data removal process
I’ve noticed that these tools handle the data removal process quite differently. First, Incogni is more of a dedicated “set-it-and-forget-it” data removal service. Once you sign up and let Incogni act on your behalf, it scans data brokers and people-search sites for your personal information. It then sends opt-out requests whenever it finds your details. Incogni keeps pushing these requests so brokers don’t have a chance to sneakily add your data back again.
On all plans, Incogni covers over 420 data broker sites. The Unlimited tiers add custom removals from over 2000 extra websites that you can submit yourself – which are then handled by Incogni’s data privacy specialists. I like that you only need to check the dashboard periodically instead of handling brokers manually.
As for Aura, I feel that its data removal is more a part of a broader cybersecurity bundle – like data removal isn’t the central focus. Just like Incogni, Aura also sends out removal requests, but to far fewer brokers and people-search sites in comparison (advertised as over 140). The issue is that Aura still needs authorization from you for some brokers – so the process isn’t as “automatic” as with Incogni.
Incogni vs Aura: ease of use
There is a significant difference in the user experience and ease of use of these two data privacy tools. Incogni is purely web-based, which means that you can only access it through a web browser. The user interface is simplistic and informative, although I'd like its data removal reports to be a bit more detailed.
Aura's design is entirely different. You can use its website to manage some features, like credit monitoring and data removal status. Otherwise, you must download the Aura app to use its VPN or an antivirus. I found the app easy to navigate, but I must admit that it is less beginner-friendly due to its wide range of features.
To make the most out of it, it's best to check Aura often, as it issues regular cybersecurity alerts upon noticing anything suspicious. Incogni aims to be a set-and-forget data removal solution, so there's no need to keep an eye on it continuously.
Aura’s software is a bit complexdue to all its features andit also occasionally requires additional user verification for more complex data removal requests. On the other hand, Incogni is a fully automated data removal service that requires minimal interaction, so it has a slight lead in terms of ease of use.
Incogni vs Aura: customer support
Thankfully, both platforms take customer support quite seriously – but in slightly different ways. First, Incogni provides 24/7 customer support, and will respond to anyone within 24 hours when contacted via their web form or via email.
When you add a subscription to the mix, you unlock live chat inside your account. Plus, Unlimited and Family Unlimited plans add phone support on top of that. There’s also a help center with FAQs if you want to troubleshoot issues for yourself.
As for Aura, the focus is on real-time help. Support is reachable 24/7/365 – according to its website – via phone or email. There’s also a separate help center with many help articles available. Aura also has live chat available from 8AM to 8PM EST – and beyond these hours, you can simply call them.
Unlike Incogni, Aura doesn’t state how long it takes to reply, but its documentation shows consistent phone availability and dedicated fraud specialists for anything urgent. Overall, I commend both services for their commitment to customer support – which is critical for brand success.
Incogni vs Aura: coverage
I highly recommend that you consider coverage when choosing between these two platforms – since coverage is one of the biggest differences between them. You must pick a service that will work in your location.
With Incogni, you have access in all 50 US states, Canada, the UK, the Isle of Man, Switzerland, Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein, and all EU member states. On its official website, Incogni states that this is because it can only act on your behalf in countries where privacy laws – like GDPR, UK GDPR, CCPA, and PIPEDA – are in force. The company explains that it must have a legal basis to reach out to data brokers on your behalf.
Conversely, Aura is much more limited in this regard – it’s US-centric. Namely, Aura’s own availability page states that it only provides coverage if you’re in the US and its territories – such as all 50 states, American Samoa, Guam, and the Northern Mariana Islands. Aura’s terms of service also explain that core identity theft protection services require a US Social Security number (SSN) and a US mailing address. Therefore, if you live in Canada, the UK, or the EU, Incogni is clearly your only option here. However, if you live in the US – both work.
Incogni vs Aura: user reviews
I’ve gone through dozens of pages of verified user feedback on each service to evaluate real-world value – and to see how well these platforms perform for real customers. First, Incogni’s Trustpilot score is 4.4 out of 5 stars based on roughly 2000 reviews – a solid start.
Users praise Incogni’s intuitive, simple setup, and many say they’ve seen a reduction in spam emails, texts, or people-search listings after using Incogni for a few months. Across Reddit, people call it a simple “set-and-forget” service. Surprisingly, others on Reddit say they saw more spam after signing up, while others criticize the awkwardness of cancelling a subscription with Incogni. Additionally, some posters said they felt uneasy about sharing more personal data with yet another company.
As for Aura, reviews were more mixed – but still positive overall. It’s got a 4.3 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot from hundreds of reviewers – though not as many reviews as Incogni.
Users praised Aura for its strong credit monitoring and identity theft protection. Users across Reddit often said that Aura effectively finds their data on data broker sites. Others appreciated having an all-in-one digital security app. On the other hand, some users noted that Aura’s security software and browser extensions are somewhat heavy or slow.
Overall, I understand that real users view Incogni as a dedicated data removal tool that carries some cancellation issues. For Aura, it’s viewed as a powerful all-in-one solution that’s sometimes clunky.
Who should use Incogni vs Aura?
Choosing between Incogni and Aura comes down to how much privacy protection you want versus how many extra security tools you need. Here’s a quick look at who each service suits best:
Incogni is best for:
- People who want an affordable, automated way to remove their data from broker sites
- Users who prefer simplicity over extra features
- Anyone focused on reducing spam, robocalls, and identity theft risk
- Those who value broad international coverage and a certified data-removal process
Aura is best for:
- Families or individuals seeking all-in-one protection (VPN, password manager, credit monitoring, identity theft insurance)
- Users who don’t mind paying more for broader security coverage
- Anyone who wants hands-on tools, real-time alerts, and strong credit-monitoring support
Incogni vs Aura: which one should you choose?
Incogni wins this comparison due to its broader personal data lookup and removal capabilities. It is also easier to use, offers better pricing, and is available in more countries. I value Incogni’s set-and-forget design, although I think its data removal request reports should be more informative.
Aura's strength lies in the scope of its features. All its plans include data removal from data brokers, alongside additional cybersecurity and identity theft protection benefits. Although that increases the prices beyond what Incogni offers, you also get an antivirus, VPN, and password manager, which is a bargain if you don't have them yet.
I recommend choosing according to your requirements. Pick Incogni if you only need data removal, and choose Aura if you want additional online security tools.
FAQ
Can I use both Aura and Incogni at the same time?
Yes, you can use both Aura and Incogni at the same time. While Aura offers a wide range of cybersecurity tools, like an antivirus, Incogni has significantly better personal data lookup and removal capabilities. You can use each at the same time to protect different aspects of your digital life.
Does Incogni remove my data from all brokers?
No, Incogni does not remove data from all data brokers. Selling data is profitable, so more data brokers appear yearly that expose your information. However, Incogni targets over 420+ (2420+ with custom removals) data broker sites, which is one of the broadest scopes in the data removal industry.
Is Aura worth it just for the identity theft protection?
Yes, Aura is worth it only for its identity theft protection alongside other online security benefits. It offers three credit bureau monitoring from the most affordable plan, and issues up to $5 million insurance on the most expensive Family plan, which is well worth its subscription cost.
How long does it take to see data removal results with Incogni?
Usually, you will notice data removal results within a few days of setting up Incogni. But because data brokers legally have up to 30-45 days to remove it, some requests may stay active for a longer time.
Is my personal information safe with Aura and Incogni?
Yes, both services use AES-256 encryption to protect your information from data leaks and unauthorized access. Additionally, you can set up two-factor authentication (2FA) for the Incogni website and Aura apps to protect your accounts from hacking.
Does Incogni provide a free trial?
No, Incogni doesn’t currently offer a free trial. Instead, it provides a 30-day money-back guarantee, allowing you to try the service risk-free and request a refund if you’re not satisfied.
What is Incogni’s ‘Custom Removals’ feature?
Introduced in August 2025, Custom Removals lets you submit URLs that aren’t part of Incogni’s automated broker list for human-assisted takedown. This feature bridges gaps in coverage by giving users personalized support for data sources that require a manual approach.
