Even the most advanced chatbots don’t recognize AI-generated videos
An experiment by NewsGuard, a media-reliability rating service, found that in most cases, leading AI chatbots couldn’t tell when videos were generated by OpenAI’s text-to-video tool Sora. Even OpenAI’s own ChatGPT is faltering.
OpenAI’s Sora is really popular among AI aficionados – and misinformation actors who like the fact that the tool is able to fool many into thinking that its videos are authentic.
For instance, not that long ago, social media platforms were full of videos allegedly showing Ukrainian soldiers begging for mercy, weeping, and surrendering on the front lines – but they were all Sora-generated deepfakes.
Now, it turns out that Sora can fool AI models themselves. A NewsGuard test demonstrated that three leading chatbots – xAI’s Grok, OpenAI’s ChatGPT, and Google’s Gemini – overwhelmingly fail to detect fake videos unless they’re watermarked.
Grok, ChatGPT, and Gemini didn’t identify non-watermarked Sora videos as AI-generated 95%, 92.5%, and 78% of the time, respectively, when prompted.
ChatGPT’s 92.5% failure rate is particularly notable, since the same company, OpenAI, created and owns both ChatGPT and Sora.
According to NewsGuard, even with watermarked videos, two of the three chatbots sometimes stumbled. Grok failed to identify watermarked content as AI-generated 30% of the time, and ChatGPT missed the mark 7.5% of the time. Only Gemini succeeded in all tests.
Moreover, these Sora watermarks are extremely easy to remove. In fact, soon after Sora launched last February, multiple firms began offering free Sora watermark removal tools. NewsGuard used one of them and easily duped all three chatbots, the organization said.
For example, ChatGPT and Gemini both failed to recognize that a non-watermarked Sora-generated video purporting to show an ICE agent arresting a six-year-old immigrant was inauthentic.
Soon after Sora launched last February, multiple firms began offering free Sora watermark removal tools. NewsGuard used one of them and easily duped all three chatbots.
In response to a NewsGuard prompt, both tools said the incident was either consistent with or confirmed by “news sources” and that it took place on the US-Mexico border.
All three models also vouched for the authenticity of a bogus Sora-generated video purportedly showing a Delta Air Lines employee kicking a passenger off a plane for wearing a “Make America Great Again” hat.
In an emailed response to NewsGuard’s inquiry regarding ChatGPT’s handling of AI content, Niko Felix, OpenAI’s head of products and applications communications, even acknowledged that “ChatGPT does not have the ability to determine whether content is AI-generated.”
He did not address NewsGuard’s questions about why this limitation is not typically disclosed to users.
Unlock exclusive Cybernews content on YouTube.
