Hume Health Body Pod vs Withings Body Scan: which smart scales are more accurate?

The Hume Health Body Pod and Withings Body Scan products are high-tech body composition scales that look and function similarly. However, they also come with enough differences to warrant a comprehensive comparison.

The interest in smart body composition scales has been growing steadily. These devices help you track several health metrics, including weight, fat mass, water percentage, bone mass, BMI, muscle mass, and more.

With such wide usability and detailed metrics that make it easier to achieve your health goals, it's no wonder these products are so popular.

In the following sections, my Cybernews team and I will give you a full comparison guide for Hume Health Body Pod vs Withings Body Scan. You’ll learn about their features, prices, accuracy, and usability, among other crucial aspects.

Hume Health Body Pod vs Withings Body Scan overview

Before I go into the thick of things, I wanted to give you a general overview of what these two devices offer. The table below will help you understand the primary similarities and differences between the Hume Health and Withings scales.

Detailed overview of each device

Below, I’ve prepared a separate overview for each device. These summaries should give you a better understanding of the two before we focus on full Hume Health Body Pod vs Withings comparisons.

Hume Health Body Pod

Hume Health Body Pod is a smart scale designed to help you reach your health and weight goals more efficiently. It does that by giving you an advanced body composition analysis with various personalized insights.

The device has 8 sensors that track 45 body composition metrics, like weight, body fat, muscle mass, BMI, and body water. The Body Pod scale does the measurements, while you get the results in a dedicated app.

The app also provides weekly health reports showing your progress and personalized workout programs based on what you need and are hoping to get.

The device itself has a square (with rounded corners), modern, and sleek design. It features high-strength tempered glass and a small 2.8” graphical display.

Visit Hume Health Body Pod

Withings Body Scan

Withings Body Scan is comparable to the Hume Health Body Pod. It sports a similar design but has less rounded edges and more details on the high-strength tempered glass. There’s an LCD color 2.8” display with a resolution of 320x240 pixels.

You can get insights on health-related metrics within 90 seconds and follow 8 metrics. It allows you to track your body muscle and fat percentages. You can also monitor various other metrics like visceral fat, calories burned at rest, total body water, and bone mass.

The device has even been cleared by the FDA for detecting atrial fibrillation (AFib) with its 6-lead ECG feature. If you pay a $9.95/month Withings+ subscription, you get added features like a cardio check-up and AI-powered personalized insights.

Visit Withings Body Scan

Pros and cons

A list of advantages and disadvantages is always useful if you’re having difficulty deciding which smart scale in the Hume Health vs Withings Body Scan battle is better. Let's cover the pros and cons of both.

Hume Health Body Pod

Withings Body Scan

Side-by-side features comparison

Continuing the trend I’ve started with my detailed Withings Body Scan vs Hume Health comparison of price and size, it’s time to do the same for the main features. Here’s a full overview:

When you take a look at the key features laid out like this, it’s clear that the two devices are very similar.

The main difference is that the Hume Health scale is geared fully toward health and weight management metrics, while Withings' scan can also detect potential signs of AFib, thanks to a 6-lead ECG. That said, Hume Health Body Pod covers a much broader range of metrics.

Despite the added measurements of the Withings device, Hume Health Body Scan is the winner, thanks to its broader range of measurements.

Pricing and value for money

Both devices have a fixed price you pay for purchasing them and then a monthly subscription if you want to get the most out of the app capabilities, while the basic functions are free.

Hume Health Body Pod is priced at $352, but is often discounted to $229, while the Withings Body Scan is $399.95, which makes it around 13%- 54% more expensive than the Hume scale.

The Hume Health or Hume Plus subscription is $9.99/month, $35 for three months, $44.95 for six months, and $69.95 for an annual subscription. The Withings+ subscription has a similar price, $9.95/month or $99.50 annually.

In other words, when it comes to price alone, the Hume Health vs Withings war ends instantly in favor of the former. However, when you consider the other measurements, Withings is also a good investment.

By default, you still get more with Hume Health Body Pod because it takes more measurements, providing an inadvertently more comprehensive picture of your wellness and fitness.

Wrapping up

The added metrics make the Hume Health device a better choice in terms of value-for-money ratio.

Winner

Hume Health Body Pod, ​​Check price today!

Accuracy and sensor technology

After thorough Withings vs Hume Health comparisons, I’ve found that both devices perform bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA).

However, there’s a big difference in the number of metrics covered – the Hume Health smart scale has the upper hand with 45 metrics compared to Withing’s 8.

Moreover, the Hume Health device is more accurate, or at least advertises its level of precision, which is set at 98% compared to DEXA scans. At the same time, the Withings smart scale also claims high accuracy; however, some users have reported problems with that.

With more measurements, it’s not a surprise that Hume Health Body Pod has 8 sensors. As a result, it can provide body composition metrics like muscle mass, fat and muscle distribution, body fat percentage, and even heart rate.

Meanwhile, Withings Body Scan has 4 weight sensors and covers fewer metrics, focusing on the most important ones. That said, it also provides detailed segmental body composition analysis and has 6-lead ECG sensors that enable it to detect atrial fibrillation.

Wrapping up

Hume Health Body Pod is the winner simply because it can track more than 5x as many metrics and has proven accuracy.

Winner

Hume Health Body Pod, ​​Check price today!

App usage and connectivity

The Hume Health app is very easy to use and provides detailed measurements seconds after you step on the scale. You get an overview of all measurements so you can understand where and what can be improved.

The app also comes with various AI insights and meal scoring, all of which should help you make easier strides toward your overall goals. Plus, you get detailed reports that will help you understand your progress.

Additionally, you can find various tips, recipes, and research-backed articles from metabolic health experts. The app can sync with Apple Health or Google Health Connect so you can import your workouts and metrics like step count and sleep.

The Withings app is also straightforward, although it’s slightly less user-friendly. The scale syncs automatically with the app, so you can see your measurements quickly. It shows localized percentages of muscle and fat through a 3D visual of your body, making it easier to plan your fitness routine.

Moreover, the app provides indicators of cardiovascular risk, and the device can measure factors like heart rate and metabolic age, which may offer some insights into heart health. It works with Apple Health or Google Health Connect like Hume Health, but the AI-powered insights are unlocked with a paid subscription.

When it comes to connectivity, Hume Health only has Bluetooth, while Withings supports both Bluetooth and Wi-Fi syncing. Both come with multi-user capabilities, but the Hume Health device can handle up to 30 users compared to Withings’ 8.

Despite the differences, both apps have great tracking capabilities. However, the Hume Health scale deserves a higher recommendation because it tracks more metrics.

Wrapping up

As a whole, the Hume Health Body Pod is the winner in this Hume Health scale vs Withings scale category because it offers more insights and reports and allows a higher number of users.

Winner

Hume Health Body Pod, ​​Check price today!

Final verdict: which one to choose?

Whether you choose one or the other in the Hume Health Body Pod vs Withings Body Scan battle depends largely on your needs.

The Hume Health scale is focused on weight and fitness tracking. Yet, it also follows more metrics, is more accurate, and comes at a lower price, so it’s the overall better choice.

Meanwhile, the Withings scale is geared more toward users looking for health measurements, like AFib detection with an ECG.

Hume Health Body Pod supports more users (30 as opposed to 8 with Withings), while Withings has both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connectivity (compared to only Bluetooth on Hume Health).

Overall, if you’re a fitness-focused user or a budget buyer, the Hume Health Body Pod is the better choice. At the same time, if you’re a health-conscious individual, Withings Body Scan would be a primary consideration.

In the end, it’s fully up to you, so evaluate everything the two devices have to offer using the information I’ve provided and do your own research to make the best choice.

FAQ