1Password vs LastPass: which one is better?


1Password and LastPass are well-known password managers on the market. If you’ve been wondering which one is better for you – 1Password or LastPass – we’re here to help you make the decision. We compared both password managers’ features, security, pricing, apps, and other functionalities, which will help you decide which one fits your needs. Let’s find out if LastPass or 1Password is a better option in 2024!

1Password vs LastPass at a glance

After conducting thorough research and putting both 1Password and LastPass to the test, we found that 1Password might be more trustworthy in some aspects, as LastPass has been exposed to a data breach and lacks in other areas. 1Password also provides uncrackable encryption, has had multiple third-party audits, and offers less restrictive functionalities.

1PasswordLastPass
⭐ Rating:
4.6
3.8
🥇 Overall rank:#4 out of #17#11 out of #17
🔥 Coupons:1Password coupon 50% OFFCybernews Password Manager Coupons
💵 Price:From $2.99/monthFrom $3.00/month
✂️ Free version:14-day trialYes
🔒 Encryption:AES-256AES-256
🖥️ Platforms:Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, macOS, Android, iOS
🌐 Browser extensions:Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, SafariChrome, Firefox, Opera, Safari, Edge, Internet Explorer

1Password vs LastPass security

1Password wins in security over LastPass. Even though LastPass has better multi-factor security, 1Password is stronger in terms of privacy and third-party audits. This makes 1Password the clear winner for the security category.

Security breaches

LastPass had two data breaches in 2022, while 1Password has never been breached.

LastPass confirmed a data breach in August 2022. It was reported that the incident didn’t compromise any of the users data and that the attacker exfiltrated portions of internal data back then. However, in late November of 2022, LastPass confirmed another breach. After this breach, it was admitted by LastPass that the attacker gained access to certain elements of the customers data. Moreover, in 2015, threat actors managed to access their network and LastPass asked users to change their Master passwords.

In contrast, 1Password has never been breached, making it more secure than LastPass.

Encryption

1Password and LastPass use top-notch 256-bit AES encryption, making them highly secure. However, 1Password adds an extra safeguard with a Secret Key, which is required alongside your master password to access your vault. This additional step doesn't mean stronger encryption, but it does make 1Password's overall security tighter, significantly reducing the risk of unauthorized access to your encrypted data.

This dual-layer approach ensures that even if someone manages to guess or obtain your master password, they still cannot access your data without the Secret Key. It's an effective way to add extra protection, making 1Password a particularly secure choice over LastPass for safeguarding sensitive information.

Multi-factor security

In 1Password’s case, multi-factor security is built into the client because it requires two passwords on every new device. Aside from this secret key, it’s possible to set up two-factor authentication via authenticator apps like Authy or Microsoft Authenticator. There’s an option to send push notifications to confirm login requests via Duo Security. It’s also possible to use Windows fingerprint or Apple’s FaceID. However, that’s about it. You won’t find third-party authenticators or USB tokens. Those two might be vital if you’re a business owner.

multifactor authentication options

What LastPass does well are its multi-factor authentication options (you can see them in the image above). Ultimately, they have the most of all password managers. The list includes TOTP (time-based one-time password) apps, physical authenticators, smart cards, and more. The kicker is that you can use several authentication options. You can even enable them all and require to use the TOTP app, biometrics, PIN, and smart card – all at the same time. On the other hand, from multi-factor authentication options, there are many reports that FaceID sometimes doesn’t work well with 1Password.

In the multi-factor security category, LastPass emerges as the winner over 1Password. LastPass provides a variety of authentication methods, including TOTP apps, physical authenticators, smart cards, and more. These options can be combined for added security, making it challenging for hackers to breach. Therefore, LastPass is the preferred choice for strong multi-factor authentication.

Privacy policy

1Password is transparent about how it operates, storing data securely in encrypted form and not selling customer information. Since it's a paid-only service, there's no incentive to capitalize on user data. Recently, 1Password was acquired by Accel company, which invested $200 million, focusing on safety.

On the other hand, LastPass, owned by LogMeIn, has a less clear privacy policy. It's uncertain what data LastPass collects, but they mention using it for marketing. Additionally, LastPass offers a free version, raising privacy concerns.

Overall, 1Password's straightforward approach to privacy makes it a better choice than LastPass.

Third-party security audits

When it comes to third-party security audits, there’s only one thing that you should know. 1Password has undergone several security audits. You can familiarize yourself with each of them, including the detailed audit reports on this page. The most noteworthy are:

  • Service Organization Control Type 2 certificate
  • Private bug bounty program for Bugcrowd, Inc.
  • Independent Security Evaluators penetration and code test

That’s a remarkable 1Password achievement few password managers can match. In contrast, LastPass only has one audit focused on internal compliance rather than thorough software testing. This makes 1Password the clear winner in terms of third-party security audits.

LastPass vs 1Password: ease of use and setup

Both password managers have created a wide array of options for their users. You can pick between the usual set of apps and clients. The main difference points include browser add-ons. 1Password is lacking in this department, forcing its users to install a desktop app if they want the browser add-on to work. However, 1Password is noticeably superior when it comes to mobile apps, especially its iOS variants. It allows you to store items even on your Apple Watch. Overall, 1Password still comes off as the superior choice compared to what LastPass has to offer.

Web client

It’s most likely that your journey with either service will start via a web client. When you create a 1Password account, you’ll be able to manage your vault right off the bat. The sign up procedure not only requires you to confirm your email with a confirmation code, but it will also enforce a randomly generated 34-character Secret Key. Plus, your login might belong in 3 different regions: 1Password.ca, 1Password.eu, ent.1password.com, or 1Password.com. Although it might seem confusing, it works to your safety advantages. There is much more variation than just your email/master password combination. The redeeming aspect is that you only have to type in these things once. Your browser or app will remember the data. You’ll only need to confirm your identity with a master password. 1Password’s web client offers more or less the same vault management options as those available on the apps. There’s also an option to use a QR code to setup or retrieve your account. LastPass has a slightly different take on their web client.

Choosing between 1Password and LastPass depends on your preferences: if you value consistent functionality across devices, LastPass is the better choice; if you prefer platform-specific features, then 1Password might be more suitable.

Desktop apps

1Password apps come in different versions. If you have a newer computer, you’ll be able to download 1Password Version 7. If you have an older computer, you can use 1Password 4. It’s rare that a password manager willingly extends support for older machines. With that said, they are no longer supported as fully and only receive the most critical security updates. All the current apps are available for macOS, Windows, and Linux.

1Password desktop app

You can manage your vault in 1Password desktop the same way you would on the web client. The difference is that the apps add advanced options. For example, on Mac, you can enable Spotlight and 3rd party app integrations. This allows searching the data stored in the items and more.

lastpass vault screen

In contrast, LastPass creates zero initiative to switch to a desktop app. Everything you can do on your web client, you can also do on their desktop app. In reality, you can better manage multi-factor authentication options via web client, expand your plans, and more. It raises the question about the purpose of the app.

1Password excels over LastPass in desktop app functionality, offering advanced features like Spotlight and seamless integration with third-party apps on Mac. With dedicated versions for newer and older computers, 1Password provides a more versatile and user-friendly experience than LastPass.

Browser extensions

If you think that 1Password’s browser extension will provide convenience, prepare for confusion. There are actually two separate versions that you can find: 1Password X and an extension that requires a desktop app. The latter was the first introduction, so it worked with Mac and Windows. Then 1Password X was released for ChromeOS and Linux users. 1Password X is newer but it is underdeveloped at this point and doesn't support biometrics authentication.

The simple extension works only as a supplement to the app, not as a substitute. This begs the question why you should bother installing both: the app and the extension when there's 1Password X?

Well, 1Password now supports Safari. So, you can enjoy the new version with all the features for your extension.

1password browser extension screenshot

You can use their browser extension separately from the apps. This is the right way to do it. You get much more flexibility as a user. The extensions are available to Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Edge Legacy, Opera, and even Safari.

1Password's browser extensions provide more flexibility and support across various browsers than LastPass, offering users a seamless experience regardless of their browser preference.

Mobile apps

1Password apps are available for iOS and Android devices. Both are identical from the features perspective: you can set up both apps to autofill passwords not only on the web but on apps as well. In the iOS case, everything is rather straightforward. You’re asked to switch to 1Password in place of the iCloud Keychain. If you’re using Android, it depends on your version. Currently, 1Password supports autofill on apps and browsers from Android version 5 to the current 12th. So, 1Password pretty much covers all bases.

Feature-wise, the most noteworthy addition on iOS is the possibility to add items to the Apple Watch keychain. That way, you can store passwords in the storage on your watch. It protects your items with your Apple Watch rather than your master password. Android devices don’t have an equivalent feature.

LastPass android app screenshot

LastPass also features autofill for Android and iOS. However, the difference is that LastPass will require the Android 8 framework to work. If you have a phone that runs on an older build of Android, you’re out of luck. You can also set up biometrics authentication if you don't want to use your master password.

1Password is a better choice than LastPass because it offers wider Android compatibility and unique iOS features like Apple Watch integration, making it a more comprehensive and appealing option for users across different platforms.

Password sharing

In terms of password sharing, with 1Password you can share items with recipients that aren’t 1Password users. The feature for that is called Psst! (Password secure sharing tool) All you need to do is just open an item to get a link, which you can share with anyone.

With LastPass you can share credentials only with other LastPast users. You can also manage the access to the login credentials. A downside is that LastPass asks you to verify your email address before letting you share anything quite frequently.

1Password definitely beats LastPass in this field, as the first one offers more functionality and versatility than LastPass and is more user-friendly. That’s something to take into consideration while making the choice between the two.

Recovery methods

Both 1Password and LastPass have recovery methods if you accidentally lose your private key (master password).

1Password offers a Windows Hello (biometric identification) recovery option. If you belong to a Family plan, other members can recover your account. However, it’s recommended to print out the Emergency Kit with all the login details.

LastPass provides a Recovery One-Time Password and login with it if you forgot your Master password. You can also add a recovery phone number or set up a mobile account recovery with biometric authentication.

Having compared the recovery methods that both of the password managers offer, LastPass seems to provide more choices and beats the one option that 1Password offers.

Password generator

It’s crucial to use secure passwords online. Unfortunately, a lot of users tend to reuse the same passwords over and over again or lack complexity when creating those. Therefore, password managers include a password generator, which generates you a secure, custom, and strong password. Both 1Password and LastPass have these.

1Password’s password generator has up to 100 characters. You can generate passwords from random symbols, PIN codes, or memorable phrases containing 3 to 15 words.

Meanwhile, LastPass password generator is rather simple and you can create a password containing up to 99 characters.

Both providers have good generator features but 1Password has more options to play with.

1Password and LastPass pricing

Although LastPass has a free version available, unlike 1Password, its past security breaches and lack of security audits make it a less viable option. Plus, while the prices of both services are fairly similar, 1Password ensures much better value for your money.

Version1PasswordLastPass
Free$0.00
Personal/Premium$2.99/month$3.00/month
Families$4.99/month$4.00/month
Check PricingCheck Pricing

Neither of the services offer money-back guarantees, making it harder to pick one as you’re committing long term. However, 1Password does come with a free 14-day trial while LastPass offers a 30-day trial, so you have some time to decide whether you want to stick with it or not.

Overall, 1Password has better pricing options than LastPass as it gives you a better bang for your buck considering its security, feature array, and more.

1Password or LastPass: Free vs Premium plans

While 1Password doesn’t have an unlimited free version available, LastPass does. With it, you get unlimited password storage in your vault, support for any device type, a password generator, multi-factor authentication, and 50 MB of data storage. This kind of data storage is rather limited.

Plus, you’ll be restricted to one device – desktop or mobile. So, accessing the same vault on your mobile and your PC is out of the question. You'll need a Premium or Family plan for that.

Speaking of premium plans, both 1Password and LastPass are very similar. Both password managers offer unlimited passwords on unlimited devices, 1GB of storage, and two-factor authentication. The prices are almost the same - 1Password costs $2.99/month, while LastPass costs $3.00/month.

1Password IndividualLastPass Premium
Unlimited passwords✅Yes✅Yes
Unlimited devices✅Yes✅Yes
Number of users11
Secure file storage1GB1GB
Two-factor authentication✅Yes✅Yes
Travel mode✅Yes❌No
Price$2.99/month$3.00/month
Try 1PasswordCybernews coupons

However, if you’re in need of a password manager for multiple users, 1Password and LastPass offer almost identical family plans. Unlimited devices, private user accounts, password sharing, account recovery – you name it, they have it all.

However, LastPass allows more users than 1Password. Yet again, we have to keep in mind that LastPass is less secure considering the previous data breaches.

1Password FamiliesLastPass Families
Unlimited devices✅Yes✅Yes
Number of users56
Private accounts for each user✅Yes✅Yes
Sharing of passwords and secure notes✅Yes✅Yes
Account recovery✅Yes✅Yes
Price$4.99/month$4.00/month
Try 1PasswordCybernews coupons

All in all, both 1Password and LastPass are great in terms of pricing. They offer all of the essential features and are in a similar price range. Yet, while 1Password also offers unique features like Travel mode, LastPass allows a bigger number of users on the Families plan.

LastPass vs 1Password: customer support

Since 1Password is positioning itself as a premium password manager, it comes with more customer support options. You can contact them via Twitter, email, or community forums. Email seems like a no-brainer, but many users report that they got in touch faster by using Twitter or the forums. Live chat would be the best option, but seeing how little password manager providers can do to help you out, this is no surprise.

When it comes to LastPass, if you’re using the Free version, you’re left without customer support. You’ll only be able to read the FAQ section. Paid users can get Premium Support tickets. So, essentially, customer support in LastPass' case is left behind a paywall.

Both services look decent from a customer support standpoint. 1Password seems a little better because of their community forums, which give them a narrow edge. LastPass should be an example of how not to implement customer support. Giving this option only to paying users is cruel.

1Password vs LastPass video review

If you’re more of a visual learner, you can check out our 1Password vs LastPass comparison where we cover security, unique features, pricing, and user experience.

Is 1Password better than LastPass?

Deciding between LastPass and 1Password depends on your preference. 1Password has an easy-to-use interface with a Secret Key and robust security. LastPass offers free access and premium features at an affordable price. Your choice revolves around weighing the importance of security against affordability.

Category1PasswordLastPass
Security✅Yes❌No
Features✅Yes✅Yes
Pricing & Plans✅Yes❌No
User-friendliness✅Yes❌No
Customer support✅Yes❌No

Other password manager reviews from Cybernews:


FAQ

Comments

Mark Stouffer
prefix 1 year ago
1Password does offer 2FA (MFA). I just used it. It auto-fills the OTP even. You don't have to open a separate app and then type it in. 1Password fill in the OTP for you. Very nice.
Carol Bloner
prefix 2 years ago
I am using Mac's Keychain on my MacBook Air M1, 2020. I have banking and credit card info stored as well as usual personal miscellaneous for 80-year-old. Does the protection provided by either major password managers offset the rather onerous set up requirements for 300 sites?
CyberNews Team
prefix 2 years ago
Hello! Both Mac Keychain and a password manager are equally secure, so you don't really need to transfer your passwords to a password manager just for the sake of security. However, password managers usually offer more functions and can be easier to use.
Paul West
prefix 2 years ago
"1Password and LastPass are the names that will likely pop up the most when you’re Googling which password manager to get. "
I'm not "Googling" anything! I'm searching. If I wanted to use Google I would just use their built in password manager like I did before they started censoring everything.
Cameron
prefix 2 years ago
I just was looking at this article to decide if to jump to 1password from lastpass and this article has helped me decide to go ahead and make the jump.

I thought I'd also add that 11months after this article has been written 1password has added MFA support for microsoft authenticator and authy: https://support.1password.com/two-factor-authentication/

My main gripe with lastpass is half baked features: i.e. equivalent domains and the autofill for applications just not working well. I'm still testing out 1password as I've found it handle multiple domains/urls much better, and from the community forums (for bitwarden) they have stated that autotype/fill for applications also works with 1password.

Thank you again for this article, it has been super helpful
Maik
prefix 2 years ago
Nice review. But one thing is the pain. Really terrible and horrible.
Want to switch from one provider to another. I’m currently trying to switch from Last Pass to 1Password. The companies know each other and they know what they are exporting or importing. But the result is only junk
Only from Dashline to Last Pass was bearable.
Overall, all of them do not provide the optimal solution. Especially in the handling.
But, that is my personal experience. Am not yet 77, but still very very old 😉
J
prefix 3 years ago
1Password does support hardware keys like Yubikey!
Don Middleton
prefix 3 years ago
As a free LastPass user I am faced with upgrading or changing to a new password manager. I understand LastPass uses four trackers whereas 1Password does not do user trackers. I don’t trust trackers so this made for an easy decision – until I read your section on web browser extensions. Now I am concerned switching to 1Password can be too technical for me.
Wes Robinson
prefix 3 years ago
If i use ANY password manager, will it affect logins via fingerprint on my cellphone? what if i need to access on a different computer with out the manager? oh and the how does it react to the “IM NOT A ROBOT” that is on so many websites now.
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
Well, if you’re using a password manager, you’ll have to install it on the devices on which you want to use it. The captcha prompts have no relation to password managers, so you shouldn’t be concerned.
Karen
prefix 3 years ago
I’m wondering how an article dated 26 February 2021 has comments that are months old?

The reviews were helpful, especially where the technical difficulty of browser use was noted for 1password.
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
That’s the date when the article was last updated. The date adjusts automatically after adjustments are made to the text.
Glad that you liked it!
Sandra Tieken
prefix 3 years ago
I have a 6 year old Mac desktop as well as an iPhone. I am 77 years old and not very computer savvy. I strongly hesitate to do anything new on my computer because I’m afraid to mess things up! I really don’t have a computer ‘nerd’ to help me out. I would like to get a password manager but I’m afraid to try anything that will make things worse. I love my Mac and spend a lot of time on my phone.
I have apparently been ‘hacked’ a few times because I have had to get a new Amex card several times. Any advice?
Hans
prefix 3 years ago
Seriously, find a local teen and pay them a few bucks to help you out. I’m not a teen (I’m a disabled vet) but I routinely trade my computer knowledge for cooked dinners. 🙂
McBee
prefix 3 years ago
This is a very nice review! Many thanks!

However, one thing you missed to consider for pricing, is the option from 1Password to also one-time buy 1Password!

It‘s actually bit hidden on their website, but there is a one-time buy option. It lacks cloud integration but offers local WiFi sync and is perfect for those who don‘t want to sync via any cloud service at all. However, even if you want cloud sync, this paid version also enables iCloud sync: start syncing to iCloud on your Mac, and you are able to continue using the iOS app.
Hans
prefix 3 years ago
I I do not see the option on the 1Password website. Since LastPass is going to start charging existing customers a monthly fee for multi-device usage, I’d prefer the one-time purchase of 1Password. Can you find the link and post it in a reply, please?
JR
prefix 2 years ago
It seems to me that the only cost for the service is if you want an account with them that syncs between devices. If you use dropbox or icloud to sync, then it is free. I could be wrong, but I just tried with the iOS app and connected it to dropbox and opened a 1Password account I set up 6 years ago and everything seems to be working fine without me paying anything. For the windows version it says that when you open it you will be asked for a membership login or you can “purchase a standalone licence” – so presumably you can’t use that one without purchasing the one-time licence. You can see the additional features of the 1Password account here:
https://support.1password.com/sync-options-security/
You can download the windows version here:
https://1password.com/downloads/windows/
You can download the MacOS version here (which presumably is the same in terms of how the licence works):
https://1password.com/downloads/mac/
TH
prefix 3 years ago
I didn’t see you mention 1Password’s Travel Mode which is one of the reasons I chose it over LastPass. It might be a good feature to mention in your article.
Omar
prefix 3 years ago
I recently got a new iPhone and installed 1Password on it. I was expecting to be asked for my secret key and was getting ready to look for it but surprisingly I was able to sign in with just my login and master password. I was disturbed that I was able to get access to all of my passwords so easily. Is that secure?
Ryan
prefix 3 years ago
Yes follow-up on this please
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
You can unlock 1Password without typing in Secret Key every time you log in. It can be stored in 1Password apps and browsers you’ve used to sign it.
As long as your master password is safe, your vault is safe. A Secret key is mostly used as an off-device measure against brute force attacks. Without your Secret key, it’s impossible for hackers to crack your vault, and 1Password never gets a copy that they could store.
A Secret key can also be stored in your device backups that get transferred if you’re migrating data from the old device to the new, as well as keychains (that, in Apple’s case, sync via iCloud). So, if it were transferred that way, the app wouldn’t request a Secret key.
EJ Orsini
prefix 3 years ago
What about dark Web Monitoring? I didn’t see that 1Password has that and LastPass does. That’s a pretty big decision also no?
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
1Password does have dark web monitoring, but it’s called Watchtower. It also alerts you if your data pops up in some data breach.
Brad
prefix 3 years ago
I have a LastPass enterprise account through work, but tried to convert to 1Password for personal + family use, but although the export/import process was easy, I definitely have struggled to get the 1Password browser extensions/MacOS app(s) to work correctly.

In the end, I’m giving up on 1Password, and I’ll just subscribe personally to use LastPass’s family plan.
David Laufer
prefix 3 years ago
something I dont find in your otherwise very fine write-up. Let’s say you try the free version and decide you want to bail out. Can you go back to your old settings, or do you have to start over and redo the settings of all your passwords for every merchant and web account?
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
Hi David,
If you’re asking about 1Password, your data becomes read-only, and autofill stops working.
If you’re asking about LastPass, then you just get reverted to a free version.
Alex Calderon
prefix 3 years ago
I am able to use the 1Password Chrome extension without the need to install software on the computer. Might want to double-check that.
Justinas Mazūra
prefix 3 years ago
That’s because you’re using 1Password X password manager. It doesn’t require an app and I was using 1Password extension which does require it 😀
Regardless, I will update the comparison as noted.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are markedmarked