Is identity theft protection worth it?

As someone deeply immersed in digital privacy and security through my work at Cybernews, I’ve seen firsthand how identity theft has evolved into a sophisticated and frequent threat. In 2025, identity theft is more rampant than ever – striking every 22 seconds. With 5.7M reports and $10.2B in losses, it’s clear the threat is real.

So, I teamed up with our research team to evaluate whether identity theft protection services are worth the cost or simply another layer of noise in an already overwhelming digital world.

We went deep into the features, prices, and protections offered by leading services. This article is the product of that research – grounded in facts, guided by real risk scenarios, and designed to help you make a smart, informed decision.

What is identity theft protection?

Identity theft protection services are designed to monitor your personal data, detect misuse, and help you recover if fraud occurs. These services vary widely but often include:

• Credit monitoring. Tracks your credit activity with one or more bureaus and alerts you to new accounts or hard inquiries
• Fraud alerts and notifications. Real-time alerts for suspicious activity tied to your Social Security number, address, or financial accounts
• Dark web monitoring. Scans hacker forums and data dumps for signs of your personal information – for breached emails, SSNs, passwords, and more
• Identity recovery assistance. Access to specialists who guide you through restoring your identity and clearing fraudulent accounts
• Insurance coverage. Reimbursement – typically up to $1M – for out-of-pocket expenses tied to identity theft, including legal fees or lost wages

Some services bundle additional tools like antivirus software, password managers, or VPNs, but the core value lies in monitoring and recovery.

Who needs identity theft protection?

Identity theft protection isn't for everyone – but some groups face significantly higher risks due to their online behavior or life stage. Here’s who should consider it most seriously:

• Frequent online shoppers. Payment data is constantly shared across sites and services, increasing exposure
• People with high net worth. Wealthy individuals are prime targets for financial fraud and account takeover
• Seniors. Older adults may be less tech-savvy and more vulnerable to phishing and scams
• Parents of minors. Children’s SSNs are often used in synthetic identity fraud because they aren’t actively monitored
• Remote workers and frequent travelers. Using public Wi-Fi and logging into multiple devices can increase exposure to cyber threats

If your lifestyle matches any of these categories – or if you’ve already experienced fraud – protection may be well worth it.

How much does identity theft protection cost?

Prices of identity theft protection typically range from $7 to $30 per month, depending on the depth of monitoring, support, and the number of users covered.

Here’s how 4 leading providers compare:

Most providers offer multi-user plans for families at a discount. The higher the cost, the more comprehensive the coverage – including all three credit bureaus and more generous insurance limits.

How to choose the best identity theft protection service for your needs?

To help you decide, I teamed up with the Cybernews research team to examine leading identity theft protection services. Here are the key factors we prioritized:

• Coverage. Does it include real-time alerts, dark web scanning, and monitoring of all three credit bureaus?
• Recovery support. Will you get hands-on help and reimbursement in case of a breach?
• Credit monitoring. Are all three bureaus (Equifax, Experian, TransUnion) covered?
• Family protection. Are kids and spouses included in the plan?
• Ease of use. Is the interface intuitive, and are alerts actionable?

Final verdict: is identity theft protection worth it?

After reviewing top services with the Cybernews team, I believe identity theft protection is worth it – but only for those whose lifestyle puts them at higher risk.

If you're living paycheck-to-paycheck, even a small fraud event can cause serious setbacks. An affordable service like NordProtect offers solid coverage and insurance, making it a smart safety net.

For parents managing a household, services like Aura offer family-wide monitoring and tools that simplify digital safety across devices and accounts.

If your online activity is limited and you already monitor your credit, free tools may be enough. But for most people with active digital lives, paid protection offers meaningful support and peace of mind.

FAQ