© 2022 CyberNews - Latest tech news,
product reviews, and analyses.

If you purchase via links on our site, we may receive affiliate commissions.

Keeper vs 1Password: comparing 2 top password managers


Keeper and 1Password are extremely popular with those looking for an advanced solution to safeguard their sensitive data. Keeper is known for its well-rounded, feature-rich, and secure service, while 1Password flaunts affordability, strong encryption, and a wide variety of browser extensions.

So, which is the password manager for you? In this Keeper vs 1Password comparison, we’ll see how the 2 password managers measure up when it comes to security, features, plans and pricing, ease of use, and more.

Keeper vs 1Password – an overview

Keeper1Password
⭐ Rating:
4.8
4.5
🥇 Overall rank:#2 out of #13#5 out of #13
🔥 Coupons:Keeper coupon 50% OFF1Password coupon 50% OFF
💵 Price:From $1.46/monthFrom $1.50/month
✂️ Free version:No14 days trial
🔒 Encryption:AES-256AES 256
🖥️ Platforms:Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS
🌐 Browser extensions:Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera, Internet ExplorerChrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, Safari

Keeper vs 1Password: which one is more secure?

This Keeper security vs 1Password matchup is closely-contested and ends with a draw since they have their respective hits and misses. However, overall, both use the uber-secure 256-bit AES encryption, support multi-factor authentication, and were rigorously audited. Meanwhile, their privacy policies, while not perfect, are pretty standard in the industry.

The only obvious weak point here is their low data storage capacities.

Encryption

There’s no sweating about encryption whether you go for Keeper or 1Password, as both password managers meet all expectations with end-to-end encryption.

Keeper opts for military-grade 256-bit AES encryption, a powerful cipher that uses a key length of 256 bits for encryption. It’s considered practically unbreakable, and it’s also the current industry standard for password managers. Keeper also adds PBKDF2 to the mix to protect your credentials and other sensitive data from brute-force attacks.

1Password has a rather similar encryption model, too. It also uses 256-bit AES encryption and beefs up security even further with measures like PBKDF2 and a 128-bit secret key.

Plus, both Keeper and 1Password have a zero-knowledge policy in place. So, all encryption/decryption is done locally, and your sensitive data is also concealed from the company’s employees.

Overall, both password managers ace encryption flawlessly, but 1Password’s 128-bit secret key gives it that extra kick.

Multifactor security

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) is an extra but incredibly helpful layer of protection against breaches. In brief, it requires additional identity verification that goes beyond just username and password. Here, Keeper has a wide range of authentication options, while 1Password’s options are considerably more limited.

Keeper offers a large variety of two-factor authentication (2FA) methods. Among other things, it supports:

  • TOTP generator apps like Google Authenticator and Microsoft Authenticator
  • Hardware tokens
  • U2F-based physical keys such as YubiKey
  • Smart wearables like Apple Watch

Plus, SMS verification is also allowed when using Keeper. But, I’d advise against this as it’s vulnerable to hijacking and is the least secure method of 2FA.

As for 1Password, you can set up 2FA with authenticator apps like Authy or Microsoft Authenticator. Alternatively, you can send push notifications to confirm sign-in requests with Duo Security.

Windows’ fingerprint and Apple’s FaceID are supported, too. But, multiple reports have shown that FaceID sometimes doesn’t work well with 1Password.

Data storage

With Keeper, you get unlimited password vault storage. This is a huge advantage, especially if you follow security experts’ advice to have different passwords for different accounts.

However, if you want to store data other than passwords, you’ll need to spring for its Family plan. The plan provides 10GB of storage that you can use to store files, photos, videos, and more.

Keeper storage

If you need an even bigger storage vault, Keeper also offers Secure File Storage. You can choose among its 10GB, 50GB, and 100GB plans. And, for businesses, its limit goes up to 10TB. Prices start from $0.83/month.

1Password, on the other hand, includes 1GB of storage in its 1Password and 1Password Families plans. That’s enough for passwords, documents, and the likes but likely far too limiting for things like videos.

Meanwhile, its 1Password Business users get 5GB. However, each file cannot exceed 2GB in size.

Privacy policy

Both Keeper and 1Password have a zero-knowledge policy, which is pretty standard for password managers but still very much appreciated. This essentially means that all your data is end-to-end encrypted, and even their employees have no way to access or view the data. However, they do collect some user information.

In Keeper’s case, it collects “limited personal information,” including username or email address and phone number, for account verification and 2FA authentication.

Beyond that, it also collects and logs aggregate user statistics and website traffic for service improvement, performance tracking, and website administration. This includes website traffic statistics, date and time of visits, browser types, and frequency of visits.

Meanwhile, 1Password is more aggressive with its data collection. It collects various personally identifiable information like:

  • Types of account
  • Payment methods
  • Log-ins
  • Number of items in vault
  • Storage space utilized
  • IP address
  • Email address.

Although, the password manager quickly emphasizes that this information is never shared with third parties.

Third-party security audits

Both password managers have undergone several third-party security audits, which is great since these audit reports will lend credence to their claims.

In Keeper’s case, it’s Service Organization Control (SOC 2) compliant. This audit assesses 5 trust service principles: security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy. Beyond that, it’s also ISO 27001, which outlines the requirements for an information security management system (ISMS), certified.

Keeper security audit

Plus, Keeper complies with the EU-U.S. Privacy Shield Framework, too. This framework regulates data protection requirements for transatlantic exchanges of personal data.

Similarly, 1Password went through various audits by independent firms, too. To start, it’s SOC 2 certified. Besides that, it regularly requests auditing agencies Recurity Labs, Cure53, and Secfault Security to perform penetration tests on its products.

Additionally, agencies like ISE, Onica, AppSec, nVisium, and CloudNative also audited several other aspects such as code review and infrastructure configurations audit.

Keeper vs 1Password: features overview

The Keeper password manager vs 1Password feature comparison sees Keeper coming out ahead. Both of them have the essentials covering password importing, sharing, generating, and recovery as well as autofill.

But, where Keeper delivers seamless processes and convenient quick access, 1Password’s processes and implementation are clumsier and slightly more dated.

Password importing

You won’t be left hanging whether you go for Keeper or 1Password as both make things very easy in this regard. But, Keeper has the upper hand with its extensive password importing options.

With Keeper, there are plenty of ways to import data into your vault. First up is via Keeper Importer, which automatically imports unprotected passwords from web browsers Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Internet Explorer, and Opera.

Keeper password importing feature

Keeper also supports importing from a long list of other password managers. Among them are 1Password, EnPass, LastPass, KeePass, RoboForm, and ZOHO. Plus, Keeper allows importing from .CSV file, Excel, JSON file, and Commander CLI.

In contrast, 1Password offers an easier way to import passwords only to an exclusive list. For browsers, you can transfer passwords from Chrome, Firefox, and Safari. Other third parties on this short list include Dashlane, KeePass, KeePassx, LastPass, RoboForm, and Thycotic Secret Server.

For everyone else, it supports password importing from .CSV files and .1pif.

Account and password recovery

Keeper and 1Password both have several account recovery methods, but Keeper races ahead with its significantly easier and more fail-proof options.

With Keeper, you can select 5 contacts who can access your vault in case of an emergency. That said, the same feature is equally helpful in case you forget or lose your master password.

Additionally, Keeper requires all new accounts to set up a security question. It’s enabled by default, and you’ll need to answer the question correctly to reset your master password.

Keeper password recovery

Meanwhile, 1Password advises that you should first turn to your Emergency Kit. It’s a PDF document where your account details and your password can be stored. This will help you to access your account in cases when you fail to sign in. 1Password also emphasizes that you should store both digital and printed copies.

Otherwise, you’ll have to resort to potentially recovering using third parties’ security recognition systems like Apple’s Touch ID or Android’s Biometric Lock.

Alternatively, if you’re on 1Password’s Family, Teams, Business, or Enterprise plans, there’s also an option for the family organizer or team administrator to restore access for other family or team members.

Password generator

Password generators are a standard yet indispensable tool for password managers. Both Keeper and 1Password have absolutely no trouble in this aspect, which is expected considering their pedigree.

In Keeper’s case, you can set the length of the password and the types of characters to include. The maximum character length is 100, which is more than enough to create a strong unique password to protect your accounts.

Keeper password generator

Likewise, 1Password has a password generator to create secure passwords, too. Its Smart Password Generator selects 4 syllables – one entirely in uppercase – and combines them with separators chosen from numerals and basic symbols.

1Password password generator

Overall, I’d say it’s fair to call a tie here. Both Keeper and 1Password’s password generators live up to expectations.

Password sharing

For password sharing, Keeper has One-Time Share. This feature provides time-limited secure sharing of records with anyone – whether Keeper users or otherwise. You can use it to share login credentials, encrypted files, and more.

The feature allows you to send links to the recipients via assorted channels, including direct QR code scan, airdrop, email, and SMS.

For added protection, One-Time Share is also device-locked so that the records are decrypted locally on the original recipient’s device. Plus, all requests to the server are signed with elliptic-curve cryptography (ECDSA), one of the more complex forms of digital signature.

Keeper password sharing

1Password lets you share copies of passwords and saved items with a link as well. You can set who to share with and when the link expires.

1password password sharing

And, for those on 1Password’s Families and Team & Business plans, there’s also an option to share a vault. Everyone with access to the vault can view, create, edit, and more. Of course, you can always manage the permission, too.

Autofill

Both Keeper and 1Password provide Autofill for quick and easy access to your accounts. Once enabled, username, password, and other information like payment details are all automatically entered.

For Keeper, it mostly relies on KeeperFill to automatically fill login credentials for saved sites. It can be used along the app but is also available for installation separately. In the latter’s case, it will either be as a browser extension or as a system-tray item.

Keeper autofill feature

Otherwise, you can also set up hotkeys by choosing a button to immediately launch KeeperFill, which will then autofill the login credentials for even faster access.

In contrast, 1Password’s autofill feature is more cumbersome. To sign in, you must first click on the 1Password icon in the username or password field, click on the login item, and click on Search 1Password if it suggests more than one item. That’s a whole lot of clicking before you can even access your account.

1Password autofill feature

Plans and pricing

In the 1Password vs Keeper pricing faceoff, Keeper has the edge, but they share some similarities. In addition to their various business plans, both have one personal and one family plan at very similar price points. Additionally, both don’t offer free plans.

PlanKeeper1Password
Unlimited/Personal (1 user)$1.45/month$1.50/month
Family (5 users)$3.12/month$2.50/month
Try KeeperTry 1Password

Where Keeper has the most advantage is that its plans are more generous with features. Plus, it has a 2x longer free trial at 30 days in comparison to 1Password’s 14-day trial. Although, 1Password’s family plan is slightly cheaper.

Keeper pricing

Keeper keeps things very streamlined and offers only 2 personal plans:

  • Keeper Unlimited – $1.45/month for 1 user
  • Keeper Family – $3.12/month for 5 users

Entry plan Keeper Unlimited is an ideal fit for most lone users. The plan allows for only one user but can be used on an unlimited number of devices. It comes with all the essentials like 256-bit AES encryption, 2FA, unlimited password storage, autofill, password generator, and secure sharing.

If you need the subscription to cover more users, Keeper Family is the plan for you. In addition to everything you get in Keeper Unlimited, it also comes with 5 private vaults and 10GB of secure file storage.

1Password, too, has 2 personal plans:

  • 1Password – $1.50/month for 1 user
  • 1Password Families – $2.50/month for 5 users

Both packages are rather similar and don’t place a limit on the number of devices.

1Password comes with unlimited password storage, 1GB of document storage, travel mode, 2FA, and autofill for only one user.

And, you get those things with 1Password Families, too. But, the plan supports up to 5 users. Additionally, it comes with share vaults, access/permission management, and account recovery.

Platforms, interface and ease of use

Both Keeper and 1Password are compatible with all the common operating systems. But, Keeper has the advantage here since it offers more browser extensions.

Keeper1Password
Supported OSWindows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, macOS, Linux Android, iOS
Browser extensionChrome, Safari, Firefox, Opera, Edge, Internet ExplorerChrome, Safari, Firefox, Edge, Brave
Number of usersUp to 5Up to 5

Unlike 1Password, Keeper also has extensions for Opera and Explorer. Although, the latter isn’t that much of a huge win now since Microsoft has retired Explorer.

1Password isn’t that far behind, either, as it offers an extension for Brave, which isn’t in Keeper’s repertoire.

However, if we also consider ease of use, Keeper’s platform, apps, and extensions are more intuitive and easier to navigate.

Desktop apps

Keeper’s desktop app works on Windows, macOS, and Linux devices. From setup to management, the app is all about simplicity. To start, installation is a breeze and can be done in a matter of minutes.

Keeper desktop app overview

Plus, the interface itself is sleek, neat, and straightforward. Every feature is clearly organized, and there’s quick access to the vault, identity and payment details, security audit, and deleted items.

Meanwhile, 1Password’s desktop app also works on Windows, macOS, and Linux devices.

1Password desktop app overview

In comparison to Keeper, 1Password’s setup is equally easy but the app takes some getting used to. And, it’s slightly clunky as it requires more clicking before you actually get to the feature you need. Slightly troublesome, but not enough to be a deal-breaker.

Browser extensions

Keeper is compatible with all of the major browsers – Chrome, Safari, and Firefox – but also works on the soon-to-be-retired Explorer, Opera, and Edge. Setup requires just a click to add an extension to your browser.

In addition to autofill, Keeper’s extension also offers access to a few other basic features like a password generator and account switching. But, that’s about it, which is pretty standard for a password manager. All other features are only available via the web app.

In contrast, 1Password’s extension works with Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Edge, and Brave. Similar to Keeper, 1Password’s setup also requires just a click.

1Password browser extensions

But, the extension isn’t as smooth or independent as Keeper’s version. 1Password’s version requires more clicking and searching before you can log in. Plus, redirects to the web app are very common.

Mobile apps

Keeper’s mobile apps are available in both Apple App Store and Google Play Store. While the Android and iOS versions sport different looks, they’re both equally intuitive and fully functional. You’ll find all the same features as its browser and desktop apps here. The only exception is that you’ll not be able to export/import passwords on the mobile apps.

Keeper mobile app

1Password apps are available for iOS and Android devices, too. Whether Android or iOS, the mobile apps look rather similar – clean, modern, and organized. I have no complaints here.

1password mobile app

Instead, my disappointment lies in its functionalities. It only provides the very basic features like autofill, and that’s about all you get with the mobile app. You certainly won’t find the full spectrum of features here.

Customer support

Keeper and 1Password both offer multiple customer support options but no live chat.

Keeper’s knowledge base should be your first go-to in times of trouble. It’s extensively stocked with thousands of detailed guides, how-tos, and even videos to help beginners and experienced users alike. The help page also displays Keeper’s server status.

For agent assistance, Keeper has a 24/7 ticketing system. You won’t get immediate replies but the response times are typically very reasonable. And, the agents are always efficient and more than helpful.

1Password, too, prefers that you ransack their massive knowledge base before everything else. Otherwise, you could also get help via email, Twitter, or community forums. The latter 2 options tend to yield a faster response than email.

Overall, it’s a tough call as both password managers’ assistance could certainly be more available to their users. But, Keeper has the edge here with its 24/7 ticketing system and faster response times.

Keeper vs 1Password – which one to choose?

Ultimately, Keeper is a better password manager than 1Password. Its strong security with unyielding encryption and authentication options are a huge plus. Beyond that, its robust features, affordability, and great compatibility are all points in its favor.

CategoryKeeper1Password
Features
Pricing & plans
Security
User-friendliness
Customer support
Compatibility

Although 1Password put up a good fight with its powerful security, its features are more elementary, dated, and restricted. It’s also weaker in terms of user-friendliness, which is a huge handicap for an everyday password manager.

FAQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked