1Password vs Sticky Password: Which One’s Better?
1Password and Sticky Password are two of the more well-known and sought-after password managers on the market. Both offer advanced security and put user-friendliness at the forefront – making them suitable for beginners and experienced users alike.
However, 1Password has more features in its arsenal while Sticky Password has a higher price point. But those aren’t the only things that set them apart.
In this 1Password vs Sticky Password comparison, we take a closer look at these providers. We pay close attention to security, features, pricing, ease of use, and more. Read on to find out which is the better password manager.
|🥇 Overall rank:||#4 out of #16||#7 out of #16|
|🔥 Coupons:||1Password coupon 50% OFF||Sticky Password coupon 70% OFF|
|💵 Price:||From $2.99/month||From $29.99/year|
|✂️ Free version:||14-day trial||Yes|
|🖥️ Platforms:||Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS||Windows, macOS, Android, iOS|
|🌐 Browser extensions:||Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, Safari||Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera, Internet Explorer, Edge, Brave, Vivaldi|
1Password vs Sticky Password: Which one is more secure?
1Password is the more secure password manager in the 1Password vs Sticky Password security comparison. That said, both put up a good fight with advanced measures like 256-bit AES encryption, zero-knowledge architecture, and multi-factor authentication (MFA). Plus, their privacy policies are relatively moderate and fair.
However, 1Password got the better of Sticky Password with a few power moves. It has more robust encryption and a wider range of MFA options. Additionally, 1Password is very transparent with its security, especially in regard to third-party security audits.
In contrast, Sticky Password has limited MFA options. An even bigger slipup is that it hasn’t shared any independent security audit reports
1Password has the lead here but both password managers are on top of their game when it comes to encryption. They have very similar approaches to guarding your data.
Both 1Password and Sticky Password use 256-bit AES encryption to encrypt user data. AES-256 is one of the most secure ciphers and also the current industry standard. Additionally, the duo also uses PBKDF2 password hashing to shield your Master Password from brute force and dictionary attacks.
Plus, both password managers were built on zero-knowledge architecture. This means that only you have access to your vault and the companies as well as their employees have no way to access or intercept your data.
However, 1Password has another trump card that gives it an advantage. With 1Password, you also get a 128-bit Secret Key that is used in tandem with your account password. Given its 128 bits of entropy, your account password is impossible to guess.
For added protection, multi-factor authentication (MFA) offers another layer of security by requiring two or more identity verification methods before granting access to the vault. This is another area where 1Password outshined Sticky Password with its comparatively diverse options.
In 1Password’s case, you get several two-factor authentication (2FA) options. To start, the password manager allows 2FA with authenticator apps Authy and Microsoft Authenticator. Beyond that, it also supports 2FA using Duo Security where you confirm login requests via push notifications sent to your mobile device.
As for Sticky Password, it boasts that it offers 2FA but fails to properly clarify the options available. That said, from digging through its Technical White Paper, press releases, and blogs, we know that it supports 2FA using a one-time PIN sent via email. Additionally, it also allows Google Authenticator for Android and iOS devices.
In addition to just storing and managing your credentials, password managers also often double as a secure cloud storage vault for sensitive files. Between the two providers, 1Password’s data storage feature is more versatile and intuitive.
With 1Password, data storage is a straightforward affair. If you’re on its Personal or Families plan, you get 1GB of storage for things like photos, receipts, and wills. Meanwhile, Business users get 5GB of storage. Either way, each file must be under 2GB in size.
Objectively speaking, there isn’t much breathing room here but you should manage just fine if you keep it to only sensitive documents.
In contrast, things are a tad more confusing with Sticky Password since it doesn’t provide data storage in the traditional sense. Instead, you get a text-only Secure Memo feature that you can use to store information like login comments, membership details, and passport data. Since it’s text-based, you’ll have to manually fill the Memos up.
Both 1Password and Sticky Password are zero-knowledge password managers, meaning that they have no access to your vault. However, unavoidably, they still collect certain personal data. The silver lining here is that the pair’s privacy policies are pretty reasonable and nothing too outrageous. Moreover, both are forthcoming about how and what they log.
In 1Password’s case, it complies with Canadian privacy laws and the GDPR. Overall, you can expect it to collect account and usage information in addition to personally identifiable information. So, information like payment methods, logins, number of vaults, IP addresses, names, and email addresses are all within bounds.
Similarly, Sticky Password also toes the line in this aspect. To start, its data collection complies with its home country Czech Republic’s Privacy Act as well as European Union’s GDPR. Among other things, it collects IP addresses, email addresses, device identifiers, operating systems and browser types, and payment information.
Third-party security audits
Third-party security audits are vital to evaluate a password manager’s security posture and identify vulnerabilities. In this respect, 1Password overpowers Sticky Password with its rigorous and regular audits.
First off, 1Password is SOC 2 Type 2 certified. Besides that, it engages Bugcrowd for a public, ongoing bug bounty program. Moreover, it also regularly retains independent firms such as Cure53, ISE, and AppSec, among others, to assess and audit its products/services.
In glaring contrast, Sticky Password has nothing to offer on this subject and doesn’t provide a single audit report from independent security firms.
1Password vs Sticky Password: features overview
1Password clinched the win in the 1Password vs Sticky Password feature comparison. Compared to Sticky Password, 1Password’s features are more functional, flexible, and intuitive. Plus, it doesn’t impose as many limitations on them.
On the other hand, Sticky Password’s features tend to be more restrictive and unnecessarily fiddly. Many of them are also only available to Premium users.
Both password managers offer bulk password-importing features for all the major browsers, file formats, and password managers on the market. Between them, 1Password has a longer list of supported applications. Plus, its entire importing process is more intuitive compared to Sticky Password.
With 1Password, you can easily import data from browsers Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Brave, and Safari with just a few clicks. Apart from that, it also supports imports from many other password managers like KeePass, LastPass, and RoboForm. For the apps that don’t make the list, there’s an alternative option to import via CSV, 1pux, or 1pif file.
Meanwhile, Sticky Password allows fewer apps for bulk password importing. However, even then, a few popular names are included on the list, such as Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer, and Opera for browsers, and 1Password, RoboForm, and KeePass for other password managers. Other formats are not nearly as abundant – only Sticky Password exported data fits the bill. So while Sticky Password’s password-importing process is nothing too complicated, it’s a tad drawn-out and clunky.
Account and password recovery
Both 1Password and Sticky Password have basic account and password recovery options. That said, note that Sticky Password’s recovery option is only for paid users.
With 1Password, your number one key to recovery is the Emergency Kit. This is a PDF document that spells out your account’s details and passwords. Heeding 1Password’s advice, you should keep both digital and printed copies of the Kit somewhere secure.
Meanwhile, users on 1Password’s Family, Teams, Business, and Enterprise plans have it easier. Here, the family organizer or team administrator can easily restore access.
As for Sticky Password, your best bet for recovery is via its Emergency Access. With this method, your predefined emergency contact can access your account after the set waiting period expires. However, bear in mind that the feature is only available if you have a Premium subscription. Plus, your emergency contact will need a Sticky Password subscription, too.
All self-respecting password managers include a password generator in their subscriptions. The tool helps you to swiftly and easily create unique and hard-to-crack passwords.
1Password offers Strong Password Generator. The generator can create the usual random passwords as well as the less-common passphrases and PINs. Beyond that, you can also tweak the perimeters to adjust password length, capitalization, and type of characters.
Likewise, Sticky Password also has a password generator. You can access the generator on your main Sticky Password app but it’s also conveniently available when you click on the password field when creating an entry. In terms of customizations, you have typical options like capitalization and the type of characters to include. Password length could go all the way up to 99 characters.
1Password’s generator is more flexible and functional while Sticky Password’s automatic password generator bubble is very handy.
With 1Password, you can share credentials and even other saved items with others using just a link. You also have full control over the access and when it expires when generating the link.
Meanwhile, users on its Families and Team & Business plans can even share an entire vault with others. The family organizer or the team administrator will have the responsibility of managing each user’s permission and access level.
Similarly, Sticky Password also has secure sharing where you can share credentials with others. However, its access rights are more restrictive in that there are only two options: limited or full rights. That’s not the worst of it. Instead, to share passwords, all the parties involved – that’s both the sender and recipient – are required to have a Premium subscription.
Overall, 1Password has the vote here with its convenient and accessible password-sharing tool. Meanwhile, Sticky Password’s decision to put the tool behind a paywall for both sender and recipient could be a deal-breaker for certain users.
Autofill is a nifty feature that speeds up the login, payment, and other form-filling processes by automatically filling up the credentials. Both providers’ autofill features are very similar to each other.
With 1Password, its autofill requires some clicking action before you can access your account. A click of the 1Password icon, then the login item, and you’re in! Now, while the process isn’t completely seamless, it’s quick, straightforward, and convenient.
In a similar fashion, Sticky Password’s autofill requires almost the exact steps. This is how you do it: click the Sticky Password icon in the input field, search through the list of existing logins for that account, and click on it.
In brief, both password managers’ autofill features are slightly clunky.
1Password vs Sticky Password: which offers better value?
1Password is the cheaper password manager when we compare 1Password vs Sticky Password in terms of pricing. But, despite its cheap prices, 1Password packed its plans with generous features. For the more cautious users, you can test out its services with its 14-day free trial before committing to a paid plan.
|Try 1Password||Try Sticky Password|
As for Sticky Password, you’re limited to just two options: a restrictive free plan or a costlier Premium plan for individual users. If you opt for the latter, there’s a 30-day refund policy just in case it’s not the right fit.
Sticky Password pricing
1Password has a slew of plans for all sorts of users. For personal plans, it offers:
- 1Password Personal – $2.99/month for 1 user
- 1Password Families – $4.99/month for 5 users
For a solitary user, 1Password Personal is the best option. It supports unlimited devices and comes with features like unlimited password storage, 1GB file storage, autofill, 2FA, 1Password Watchtower, a digital wallet, and travel mode.
To squeeze in more users, get 1Password Families. It can support up to five users and comes with everything in 1Password Personal. Plus, you also get access/permission management and account recovery.
Sticky Password pricing
Sticky Password only has two personal plans: Free or Premium. As with most free plans, its free tier includes only a handful of features like autofill, password generator, and 2FA. However, unlike other providers, it’s generous enough to also throw in unlimited password storage and a digital wallet.
Meanwhile, the premium plan costs $29.99/year. In addition to everything in Free, you also get dark web monitoring, password sharing, Emergency Access, and priority support.
Platforms, interface, and ease of use
1Password and Sticky Password both work on all the common operating systems and extensions. However, the one glaring difference is that 1Password is available on Linux while Sticky Password is not.
|Supported OS||Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS||Windows, macOS, Android, iOS|
|Browser extension||Browser extensionChrome, Safari, Firefox, Edge, Brave||Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Opera, Internet Explorer|
|Number of users||5||1|
In terms of ease of use, both have their pros and cons, so it’s the only fair to call a draw to 1Password vs Sticky Password faceoff for this round. For instance, 1Password’s modern and intuitive desktop apps triumph over Sticky Password’s dated interfaces. However, compared to 1Password, Sticky Password’s mobile apps come with a smidge more features.
1Password and Sticky Password’s desktop apps are supported on Windows and macOS devices. 1Password’s version has the benefit of also working on Linux devices. Both password managers’ installation and setup processes are quick and uncomplicated. Simply a few clicks here and there when prompted and it’s a wrap.
1Password’s desktop apps have different looks depending on your operating system. In any case, all the versions are functional, clean, and modern. They’re also a breeze to navigate.
In contrast, Sticky Password’s desktop apps look more outdated with certain UI and visual elements sorely missing. That said, they work just as they should and all the necessary features are there. You should be able to find your way around with no problem.
In brief, while both password managers’ desktop apps serve their purpose well, 1Password gets extra points for its user-friendlier modern interfaces.
The two password managers have browser extensions for all the mainstream browsers such as Chrome, Safari, and Firefox. To add the extension to your browser, just follow the onscreen instructions and click where necessary.
In terms of functionalities, you won’t see much with either of them and you can forget about getting the full range of features. Instead, just like most browser extensions on the market, their functionalities are tied to their respective web apps. So, you can expect to get basic features like autofill, autosave, and password generators but not much else.
Whether it’s 1Password or Sticky Password on iOS or Android devices, setup is a piece of cake. You just need to download the chosen app from Apple App Store or Google Play Store.
With 1Password, its mobile apps for iOS and Android are strikingly similar visually. Both versions are responsive, clean, and sleek. While only key features are available, you should be able to take care of most of your password management needs on the apps.
Meanwhile, Sticky Password’s mobile apps are designed to be a simplified version of its desktop apps but still offer the same functionalities. As for looks, the Android and iOS apps are nearly identical. Both are neat, well-organized, and responsive.
1Password has a narrow win in the 1Password vs Sticky Password matchup for customer support courtesy of its bigger selection of options.
With 1Password, your starting point in case of trouble is its well-loaded knowledge base where you’ll find thousands of articles and guides. Otherwise, you could seek out agent assistance via email or Twitter. Immediate replies are uncommon but its agents typically get back in a few hours. Alternatively, you could also try your luck by venturing into its active community forums.
Likewise, if you run into trouble with Sticky Password, start looking for answers in its huge knowledge base. Besides that, you could also reach out via email for technical support. You can expect one of its agents to get back to you within 24 hours.
1Password vs Sticky Password – which one wins?
Taking everything into account, 1Password is the better password manager in the 1Password vs Sticky Password comparison. Unwaveringly, it has every aspect well-covered with its heightened security, comprehensive and generous features, and user-friendliness. Plus, its cheap pricing means that it’s accessible to all.
|Ease of use||✅||✅|
That said, Sticky Password is still a solid password manager. It has its plus points like strong encryption, a handy password generator, and functional mobile apps. However, at the same time, it also dropped the ball in certain areas like limited MFA options, lack of independent audits, and higher pricing.
Is 1Password better than Sticky Password?
Yes, 1Password is better than Sticky Password. Compared to its counterpart, 1Password has more advanced security measures and infrastructure, better and more functional features, and user-friendlier interfaces. Additionally, you get all of these perks with 1Password at a cheaper price point compared to Sticky Password.
Which is better for mobile: 1Password or Sticky Password?
Sticky Password is slightly better for mobile. While both providers’ mobile apps are interactive and intuitive, 1Password’s mobile apps offer only the core features. Meanwhile, Sticky Password’s versions come with all the same functionalities that you’d find on its desktop apps.
Can 1Password import from Sticky Password?
Yes, 1Password can import from Sticky Password. First, export the content of your Sticky Password Vault. Then, convert the file into CSV since Sticky Password only supports export in Sticky Password database, XML, HTML, and TXT formats. Finally, upload the CSV file to your 1Password vault.