© 2022 CyberNews - Latest tech news,
product reviews, and analyses.

If you purchase via links on our site, we may receive affiliate commissions.

Keeper vs LastPass: which is the frontrunner in 2022?


Keeper and LastPass are established and well-known names in the password manager arena, and it’s easy to see why. Both password managers are feature-rich and available on a wide range of devices. Keeper is highly secure yet affordable, while LastPass puts user-friendliness first and even offers a free plan.

So, which is the best password manager for you? In this Keeper vs LastPass comparison, I’ll examine both of them closely in terms of security, features, pricing, user-friendliness, customer support, and more. Let’s dive right in!

Keeper vs LastPass – an overview

KeeperLastPass
⭐ Rating:
4.8
4.3
🥇 Overall rank:#2 out of #15#6 out of #15
🔥 Coupons:Keeper coupon 50% OFFCybernews Password Manager Coupons
💵 Price:From $1.46/monthFrom $3.00/month
✂️ Free version:NoYes
🔒 Encryption:AES-256AES 256-bit
🖥️ Platforms:Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, macOS, Android, iOS
🌐 Browser extensions:Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera, Internet ExplorerChrome, Firefox, Opera, Safari, and Edge

Keeper vs LastPass: which one is more secure?

In the LastPass vs Keeper security matchup, Keeper is the more secure option. Both come equipped with 256-bit AES encryption, multi-factor authentication, and secure storage. But, Keeper tipped the scale in its favor with its significantly more transparent and user-friendly privacy policy as well as extensive third-party audits.

Meanwhile, LastPass suffers from a vague privacy policy and a lack of independent audits.

Plus, Google Project Zero researcher Tavis Ormandy found various vulnerabilities with LastPass’ services in 2016 and 2019 – especially with its browser extensions – that could have exposed over 16 million users’ credentials.

Even though the vaults remained protected, a hacker could conceivably get hashed users’ master passwords, password reminder questions, and email addresses via the exploit. While LastPass has swiftly addressed the issues, this remains a blight on its reputation.

Encryption

Considering their caliber, it’s really no surprise that both Keeper and LastPass come up to snuff with end-to-end impenetrable encryption.

In Keeper’s case, encryption is a multi-layered affair. It uses the military-grade 256-bit AES encryption, considered the industry's golden standard and nearly impossible to crack. Alongside AES-256, Keeper also uses PBKDF2 to protect against brute-force attacks.

Plus, in line with its zero-knowledge policy, all encryption/decryption is done locally on your device. So, only encrypted passwords are sent to its servers, and the company doesn’t have access to your data.

LastPass has a very similar data-handling model. It also uses 256-bit AES encryption with PBKDF2 SHA-256 hashing for your master password, and all encryption/decryption is on the device level. There’s no possibility to reverse engineer to retrieve your master password, and there are too many potential variables for brute-force attacks, too.

In brief, Keeper and LastPass are on equal footing when it comes to encryption. Both have all the necessary mechanisms for safe data handling.

Multifactor security

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) is a crucial additional layer of protection to shield your account from breaches. Essentially, you’ll need to verify your identity with more than just a username and password during logins. In this aspect, both Keeper and LastPass are evenly-matched. Keeper supports a wide variety of two-factor authentication (2FA) methods. This includes:

  • TOTP generator apps like Google Authenticator and Microsoft Authenticator
  • Hardware tokens
  • U2F-based physical keys such as YubiKey
  • Smart wearables like Apple Watch

Plus, Keeper allows verification via SMS, but I’d urge against this. SMS verification is notorious for being the least secure 2FA method and is vulnerable to hijacking.

As for LastPass, it supports 2FA and MFA. For 2FA, LastPass offers:

  • LastPass Authenticator
  • Smartphone apps like Google Authenticator, Microsoft Authenticator, and Symantec VIP
  • Software-based authentication services such as LastPass Grid and LastPass Sesame
  • Hardware tokens like YubiKey and RSA SecurID

On top of the 2FA, Business users get LastPass MFA – which is a separate app altogether – for even more secure logins.

Data storage

Both Keeper and LastPass offer vaults for password storage that could also double as secure cloud storage options for sensitive files.

In Keeper’s case, it offers unlimited password storage. This is a great asset, especially if you’re using completely unique passwords for different accounts.

But, an upgrade to its Family plan is necessary to stash anything other than passwords. The plan comes with 10GB of storage. And, to store even more, Keeper also has Secure File Storage, which offers up to 100GB of encrypted storage. Prices start from $0.83/month.

LastPass, too, offers unlimited password storage. But, data storage for everything else is dependent on your plan.

Its free version provides only 50MB of storage space. Meanwhile, paying users on its Premium and Families plans get up to 1GB. But, either way, individual file size is capped at a very restrictive 10MB. Sufficient for passwords and maybe a few documents, but not really for much else.

Privacy policy

Keeper and LastPass are zero-knowledge services, meaning that only end users can access the vault. But, the pair collects some user data, with LastPass being the worse offender.

For Keeper, it collects ‘limited personal information’ like username or email address and phone number for account verification and authentication. Additionally, Keeper also collects aggregate user statistics and website traffic like browser type and frequency of visits for service improvement, performance diagnosis and tracking, and website administration.

LastPass’ privacy policy, meanwhile, is less optimal. For starters, LastPass shares a privacy policy with its parent company GoTo, Inc (previously LogMeIn, Inc). But, since the company offers multiple products, there’s no way to nail down the specific clauses that apply to LastPass.

Overall, some of the things it collects include:

  • First and last name
  • Billing data
  • Email address
  • Devices used
  • IP addresses
  • Location
  • Unique device identifiers

Worse, GoTo, Inc also shares your data with ‘affiliated companies and subsidiaries which are directly or indirectly owned’ and other parties.

Third-party security audits

Keeper has been audited by various independent third parties. To start, it complies with the Service Organization Control (SOC 2) – framework that outlines the criteria for managing customers’ data.

Additionally, it also meets the ISO 27001 standard. The ISO 27001 outlines the security requirements that an information security management system (ISMS) should meet under the 3 pillars of information security: people, processes, and technology. It covers 14 domains, including access control, operations security, and cryptography.

In contrast, LastPass comes up short. In 2018, LogMeIn services – including LastPass – were audited by Tevora Business Solutions to check if they meet the Trust Service Principles set by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).

While LogMeIn got the stamp of approval, bear in mind that this was back in 2018 – before its 2019 hack. Plus, LogMeIn’s across-the-board audit for staff compliance is a far cry from Keeper’s stringent as well as extensive audits.

Keeper vs LastPass: features overview

Both Keeper and LastPass provide great password importing options, multiple password recovery methods, flexible password generators, and convenient autofill features.

However, Keeper has the edge because its password-sharing feature is not only very convenient but also made available to all of its users. Meanwhile, LastPass’ password sharing is only available to certain subscribers.

Password importing

Keeper and LastPass make password importing very convenient to save you from copy-pasting hell.

With Keeper, its Keeper Importer automatically imports unprotected passwords from web browsers like Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and Safari.

Beyond that, the password manager supports imports from other password managers, too. Among those on its list are LastPass, 1Password, Dashlane, EnPass, Roboform, and ZOHO. Plus, it also allows import from CSV file, Excel, JSON file, and Commander CLI.

keeper import

Similarly, LastPass is very generous with its importing options, too. For starters, it allows imports from various browsers, including Chrome, Edge, and Safari. There’s also an option to import from other password managers like Keeper, Dashlane, and KeePass.

Password importing on LastPass

And, if your old password manager doesn’t provide exporting services, you can still extract your passwords using LastPass’ passive import function. You just need to launch the 2 password managers simultaneously. Of course, importing via a CSV file is an option, too.

Account and password recovery

Keeper and LastPass are quite forgiving when it comes to account and password recovery.

In Keeper’s case, you can pick 5 contacts who get access to your password vault in the event of an emergency. This is also your lifeline if you forget or lose your master password.

Beyond that, Keeper now requires all new accounts to set up a security question. You’ll need to provide the correct answer to reset your master password.

Keeper password recovery

As for LastPass, you can choose among mobile account recovery with Face or Touch ID, password hint, a One Time password, SMS recovery, or revert to your previous master password. Just bear in mind that you’ll have to first log in using your browser’s web extension to utilize these recovery methods.

LastPass password recovery

If none of them work, you’ll need to start fresh with a new account since LastPass has no way to reset your password.

Password generator

A password generator might be a very basic but incredibly helpful tool in the fight to avoid weak passwords. Both Keeper and LastPass have flexible password generators to help create unique passwords.

With Keeper’s password generator, you can set the length of the password as well as the types of characters – such as capital letters, numbers, and symbols. The maximum character length is limited to 100, which is more than what you’d need to create a strong password.

Keeper password generator

Likewise, LastPass’ password generator also allows the customization of password length, types of characters, and more. Additionally, you can also set the passwords to be easy to say or read as well. The default password length is 12 characters, but you can increase it up to 99 characters.

LastPass password generator

Password sharing

Keeper makes password sharing very easy for its users. Its One-Time Share feature lets you share time-limited records – including passwords, other login credentials, and encrypted files – with anyone.

keeper one time share

All the recipient needs for access is a link, which you could send through various channels like direct QR code scan, airdrop, email, and SMS.

For added security, One-Time Share is also device-locked, so the link is only accessible on the original recipient’s device. And all requests to the server are signed with elliptic-curve cryptography (ECDSA) – a complex form of digital signature.

LastPass also has a password-sharing feature. But, whether you can utilize it (and, to what extent) depends on your plan.

LastPass one-time password

Those on its Family plan can share passwords among 6 users. Meanwhile, Business plans allow unlimited users, and Teams plan users have user count capped at 50. Unfortunately, you can’t share passwords if you’re on LastPass’ Free or Premium plan.

Autofill

You’ll find that most browsers already offer the autofill feature. But, a password manager’s one is usually more secure and not restricted to just passwords.

For instance, Keeper’s autofill, if enabled, will automatically enter not just username and password but also payment details like credit card numbers and more.

Keeper’s autofill, KeeperFill, can be used along with the app. Alternatively, you can download it separately, either as a browser extension or as a system-tray item. For quick and easy access, you can also set up hotkeys to immediately launch KeeperFill.

Similarly, LastPass’ autofill also helps to quickly enter login credentials, payment details, and more. Additionally, you can also disable the feature for certain sites, such as those that pose a risk to security.

Plans and pricing

Keeper has the high ground when compared Keeper vs. LastPass pricing. While both offer 30-day free trials and assorted packages for different users, Keeper tips the balance with its significantly cheaper paid plans. LastPass also gains some ground with its free plan, even though it’s very bare-bones.

PlanKeeper LastPass
Free-$0.00
Premium$1.46/month$3.00/month
Family$3.12/month$4.00/month
Try Keeper Try LastPass

Keeper pricing

In addition to its business and enterprise plans, Keeper has 2 personal plans:

  • Keeper Unlimited – $1.46/month for 1 user
  • Keeper Family – $3.12/month for 5 users

For single users, Keeper Unlimited is the best plan. While the plan allows only one user, it can be used on an unlimited number of devices. Plus, it includes key features like unlimited password storage, autofill, password generator, and secure sharing.

Alternatively, the Keeper Family plan is ideal if you have multiple users. You get everything in Keeper Unlimited as well as 5 private vaults and 10GB of secure file storage.

LastPass pricing

LastPass has 3 personal plans:

  • LastPass Free for 1 user
  • LastPass Premium – $3.00/month for 1 user
  • LastPass Families – $4.00/month for 6 users

Its Free plan comes with an unlimited number of passwords, and that’s about it. For more features, you’ll need to upgrade to LastPass Premium. Here, you’ll get dark web monitoring, emergency access, password sharing, and more.

To get the entire spectrum of features or to accommodate more users, you’ll need to fork out for LastPass Families. It allows up to 6 users and comes with more advanced features like a family manager dashboard and unlimited folder sharing.

Platforms, interface and ease of use

Keeper and LastPass are compatible with all the widely-used operating systems in the market. But, this round of Keeper vs LastPass goes to Keeper as it supports more operating systems, including Linux.

KeeperLastPass
Supported OSWindows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOSWindows, macOS, Android, iOS
Browser extensionChrome, Safari, Firefox, Opera, Edge, Internet ExplorerChrome, Safari, Firefox, Opera, Edge
Number of usersUp to 5Up to 6

Plus, Keeper also has a browser extension for Internet Explorer. Although, this is less of a bragging right now that Explorer is retired.

In any case, Keeper still maintains its high ground with better ease of use. Its apps and extensions put user-friendliness first with intuitive design and easy navigation.

Desktop apps

Keeper’s desktop apps are available on Windows, macOS, and Linux devices. One thing you’ll notice very quickly is that its app puts user-friendliness high up on the priority list. From setup to password management, every single task and process is guided, easy, and quick.

Keeper desktop app

Additionally, the app’s interface is contemporary, well-organized, and a breeze to navigate. All features are neatly categorized, and you get quick access to the most important elements: vault, identity and payment details, security audit, and deleted items.

LastPass also has a desktop app for Windows. But, it’s only available to paid users and is a pared-down variant of its web browser version.

LastPass dashboard

Setup is easy enough and requires just a click. However, the desktop app’s limited functionality does call into question if it’s worth the trouble.

Browser extensions

Keeper offers extensions for all popular browsers, including Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Explorer, Opera, and Edge. One click is all it takes to add the extension to your browser.

As is standard with browser extensions, Keeper’s version sees its functionality tied to the web app. That said, the extension is still great for autofill and autosave. Plus, Keeper’s extension also comes with a number of other basic features like a password generator and account switching.

Meanwhile, LastPass offers extensions for Chrome, Safari, Firefox, Opera, and Edge. The installation process (if you can call it that) requires only one click.

Functionality-wise, it’s in the same boat as Keeper. You get autofill, password generator, and that’s about it all.

Mobile apps

Whether Keeper or LastPass, your mobile app setup is as easy as downloading the chosen app from either the Apple App Store or the Google Play Store.

With Keeper, its mobile apps for Android and iOS look rather different from each other, but both versions are very intuitive, visually appealing, and functional.

Keeper mobile app

In fact, all the same features found in its browser and desktop apps are available here, too. The one sole exception is that the mobile app doesn’t allow for password importing/exporting.

LastPass’ mobile apps also get an A+. They offer full-scale features – exactly like what you’ll find on LastPass’ browser and desktop apps. But, you also get some mobile-exclusive additions like autofill in apps and split-screen feature for iPads.

LastPass mobile Settings

Customer support

Keeper is the clear winner in the Keeper vs LastPass customer support faceoff. Unlike LastPass, it doesn’t force users into purchasing a plan before rendering assistance.

With Keeper, your first port of call is its knowledge base. It’s well-stocked with a wealth of elaborate guides, how-tos, and more. Plus, the help page shows Keeper’s server status, too.

Keeper also has a 24/7 ticketing system if you prefer an agent’s assistance. Generally, the response times are short, and the agents are well-trained as well as eager to help.

Meanwhile, LastPass directs you to its FAQ section for DIY help before everything else. Otherwise, it also has a ticketing system, but that’s an option only available to its Premium users.

Overall, Keeper soundly trumps LastPass when it comes to customer support. Where LastPass monetizes its customer support, Keeper freely lends a helping hand.

Keeper vs LastPass – which one to choose?

When it comes right down to it, Keeper is a better password manager than LastPass. Keeper ticks every desired box with its strong security, robust features, and great user-friendliness. And, it delivers all of the above at a very affordable price point, too.

CategoryKeeper LastPass
Features
Pricing & plans
Security
User-friendliness
Customer support
Compatibility

In contrast, LastPass’ hacking and vulnerability scandals raise doubts about its security, which is a total no-no for a password manager. Beyond that, its lack of transparency in regards to privacy and independent audits certainly doesn’t help its cause. And, finally, it’s also shabbier in terms of customer support and affordability.


More password manager comparisons from Cybernews:


FAQ

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked